Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    gwakeen's Avatar
    gwakeen Posts: 2, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Jul 8, 2011, 11:50 AM
    Superheat vs Subcooling method for adding R22
    I finally determined that my Trane has an Accutron Thermostatic Expansion Valve (TXV).
    I am familiar with the superheat method of calculation for adding R22 but have doubts about using the Subcooling method which I understand some mfgrs specify.

    I have a temperature pressure chart and Trane literature says to use 12 as a Superheat goal. Is it OK to use the Superheat method with a Trane (TRW036-SF-1A)(about 1993 model)? The chart outlines a Subcooling method for TXV systems. This seems similar except for where you measure the temperature. For Superheat chart says to determine saturated suction temperature from the chart, then for the Subcooling method says to determine saturated condensing temperature from the chart.

    What is the difference between saturated suction temperature or saturated condensing temperature?
    I believe it is the same, large pipe outside unit, suction temp as it enters outside unit.

    I have calculated Superheat from the figures the last serviceman left and one system is now at 6 and the other unit at 3. The 6 was 54 before he added 4 lbs of R22. It has been working that way for 3 years, I want to check to see if it leaked R22 in that time. From my newly gained knowledge it seems that both 6 and 3 are low for Superheat which should be 12, as above. With a TXV in mind though it may be equivalent, I don't recall where he measured the temperature but think it was outside the unit on the large pipe (suction). It looks like the subcooling method wants you to measure liquid temperature entering the TXV. So I am confused about the subcooling method. The end goal is the same, 12 per Trane, but where you measure the temp is perhaps different. Thanks much.

Check out some similar questions!

Do I have to replace the whole r22 system if I upsize from a 2 to a 2.5 ton r22 unit [ 6 Answers ]

My r22 heat pump unit is undersized for my house. It is a 2 ton and the builder should have installed a 2.5 ton. Do I have to replace the whole system, inside and out, if I upsize to a 2.5 ton or can I change out just the part that is the wrong size to cool the house? I can't really afford the cost...

These questions are directed to hvac1000.Can you explain superheat and subcooling to [ 3 Answers ]

These questions are directed to hvac1000.Can you explain superheat and subcooling to me in a way I can understand?Also,if someone accidentally added r-22 to a 410 system,what would be the effects and how long would it take to appear? Thank You

Trane chiller low superheat [ 1 Answers ]

I have a Trane helical-rotary air-cooled liquid chiller faulting for low superheat. I was wondering what causes there might be for this and or things I could look into?

Excess superheat [ 1 Answers ]

Where in the system is the excess superheat added that must be removed before condensation in the condenser can take place?


View more questions Search
 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.