Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    gturn's Avatar
    gturn Posts: 1, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Mar 26, 2011, 01:35 PM
    Stucco or hardie board for surfacing arches next to pool
    I'm looking to add a screened-in swimming pool. To keep with the spanish architecture, I would like to place stucco-covered arched walls close to the side of the pool (and use those to support the screen-roof).

    I was looking at maybe using the stucco-finished Hardie board, because it would be so much easier than traditional stucco over plywood, and so much lighter than pouring concrete arches. However, I'm running into issues that I can't find answers to, and wondering whether Hardie board is suitable for this project.

    1. Exposed corners. Can Hardie board be used on exterior corners without Hardie trim? I don't think having thick trim on all four corners of each pillar would look particularly good.

    2. 2" clearance requirement. Hardie board can only be applied down to 2" above a deck (and safe height could probably be higher than that since this is a pool deck). Any ideas on what I could use to fill in the gap? I thought about putting a stone fascia on the lowest 4' or so, and stucco higher up, but that only delays the inevitable - what could I put between the top edge of the stone fascia, and the lowest edge of the board? Here, Hardie trim might look OK, but I'm not sure it would help - wouldn't it just create a cavity behind the trim that would allow wicking of moisture into the board without any chance of drying out? Am I being overly cautious, or is this a potential solution?

    3. The curve of the arch. So Hardie board seems to be applied in planes only, and from previous experience, it is not particularly pliable for fitting to a curved surface (such as the underside of an arch), but I have found information that it can be applied to some contours by wetting. Anybody got experience on the limitations of bending this stuff. I'd be looking at about a 2.5' - 3' radius (5' - 6' archway).

    4. Any other options that I haven't considered? Should I just bite the bullet and look at doing the whole project in traditional stucco?
    joypulv's Avatar
    joypulv Posts: 21,591, Reputation: 2941
    current pert
     
    #2

    Apr 9, 2011, 06:42 AM
    1. I plan to use Hardie Plank as vertical trim, despite being only 1/4" thick and having a slight bevel. I'll just turn the angle inside.
    2. How about stone tile or copper flashing?
    3. A 12' plank can be lifted about 3' each end easily. That's not going to help your needs. The specs on it say not to get it wet. Shrinks or expands, I forget. After all, it has sawdust in it. Scoring the backside of drywall is easy because of the paper holding the showing side smooth, but that won't work with Hardie. So I don't know.
    4. Maybe combine different materials?

    Maybe a Spanish cedar pergola?
    Screen roof over a pool.. sounds like mammoth screens.. and how will you clean them?

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

How to anchor a starter board to old stucco without cracking the stucco [ 7 Answers ]

I am looking to build a wood porch onto an existing 10' x 20' concrete pad. The house is old stucco with no concrete block behind it. I have been told that by using a starter board on the house, the stucco may crack. Any ideas on how to start the roof of the porch without using a starter board?

Hardie board floors [ 2 Answers ]

How much should I be looking at paying for someone to put in hardie board floors for a area of 17x12, 18x16, 4x20, and 8x14. The hardie board we have is 1/2 inch by 3x5 feet. \ Thanks

Hardie Board on Masonry block wall [ 6 Answers ]

Thinking of using 4' X8' sheets of Hardie board to upgrade the appearance of a building that has plain masonry block walls. Can hardie board be applied directly to the block without furring strips, etc? Can it be glued to the surface with construction adhesive? Any special techniques or...

How to clean Hardie board siding? [ 1 Answers ]

Our house has Hardie board siding. It is getting covered with some kind of greenish stuff, possibly mold or moss, that does not easily wipe off. (This is New Zealand north island which has a rainy, damp winter.) Can I use sudsy ammonia cleaner to clean it? I tried this cleaner called Handy Andy,...


View more questions Search