Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    val17's Avatar
    val17 Posts: 1, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Sep 5, 2007, 03:55 AM
    Family etiquette
    My question is related to family.
    My brother in law asked my husband about the 2 of us coming to sydney to surprise their mum for her birthday.
    As their mum and dad would be coming from south australia to visit.
    I was raised that if you ask somebody to come from another city or state that you in fact are
    Asking them to your home.and they would be welcomed to stay with me .
    I asked my husband several times what the arrangements were on where we would be staying .
    He emailed his brother the day before driving to sydney and asked if we could/would be staying at their house.
    The brother emailed back and said they would be sleeping on the floor and there was no room for us.
    The brother also said he had picked a nice place to take the mother and father out to eat.
    The brother said he would be paying for his meal and that of the mother and father (for her birthday) and we would only have to pay for our meal.
    I may be wrong but this doesn't sound right.
    When I ask somebody to visit I put them up in my home and treat them as a guest in my home
    Would somebody tell me if I am wrong or over reacting in this event.
    templelane's Avatar
    templelane Posts: 1,177, Reputation: 227
    Ultra Member
     
    #2

    Sep 5, 2007, 04:09 AM
    Usually I'd agree with you but if there is no space there is no space and there is not much that can be done to alter that.
    CaptainRich's Avatar
    CaptainRich Posts: 4,492, Reputation: 537
    Cars & Trucks Expert
     
    #3

    Sep 5, 2007, 05:03 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by val17
    Would somebody tell me if i am wrong or over reacting in this event.
    Not having the room to accommodate all that your brother-in-law wants to have visit isn't such a big deal.
    The mother's travel and birthday are the key topics.
    The invitation should have been made far enough in advance that arrangements for suitable abode could easily been made early.
    They want you to be there to particpate. Just go and enjoy the celebration.
    lacuran8626's Avatar
    lacuran8626 Posts: 270, Reputation: 57
    Full Member
     
    #4

    Sep 7, 2007, 06:57 PM
    I don't think it makes sense to presume that letting siblings know that they are planning something for their mutual parents, and would like everyone to be there for the benefit of those parents, is really the kind of invitation that requires the planners to put everyone up or feed them. If this were the case, a lot of families couldn't get together because the expectations would be hard for many people to meet.

    I lived 400 miles from my family for many years. I knew I could always stay with my parents, as they had extended a standing invitation to me and my small family and had room for us. However, other's also invited us to things in our home state frequently such as get togethers at restaurants, christenings for their children, weddings, family reunions and more. These invitations normally required that we pay our own way and arrange our own accommodations.

    Unless the invitation is, "we'd love to have you come and visit us, we have plenty of room!", or "we'd like you to join us for a dinner honoring Mom and Dad, our treat", you should assume that while your relatives want to include you, the expectation will be that all but those being honored will be on their own financially and in terms of accommodations.

    In general, I find that families are so different - in one family a lot is implied that is not at all understood or traditional in another. If it's not your own family of origin, I'd suggest that if anything is in question, clarify it. For example, in this case, you might ask, "do you know if anyone might have room for us, or would we need to find a hotel?", or, "what do you anticipate the cost will be for the restaurant?" Asking in this way, you are not presuming any accommodations but rather information.

    Hope that helps!

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Eviction of a family member from a single family home [ 2 Answers ]

My brother who is about 37 years old lives with my father, sister and myself; my brother is an alcoholic and a drug addict and is verbally abusive to my father who is 71 years old and is also disabled. My father wants him to move out of the house; is there a specific amount of time, by law, that...

Dinner Etiquette [ 10 Answers ]

Hello, My son whom is 16 is dating a very nice young lady, her parents have invited us to dinner This evening. My question is , should I take something to go along w the dinner ? Thanks Slew

Blended family means family to me, should it not to my husband as well? [ 6 Answers ]

HI, I just really need to know if I am way off base here. Last night my husband told me that"you need to understand how it is going to be between my daughter and myself." " when it comes to special events, even if they conflict with your boys(his stepsons) and in the future if we have children of...

Wedding etiquette [ 10 Answers ]

Is it okay to wear a black dress/like a cocktail dress to an evening wedding?

Wedding Etiquette [ 6 Answers ]

My sister's daughter is getting married soon. Sister is widowed and dating a guy (for several months). Sister wants Date to sit with her in the first pew (Sister will be walked down the aisle to sit in first pew). Daughter says it is her wedding and she does not want date to sit in the first pew...


View more questions Search