Originally Posted by nikosmom
Your homeowner's doesn't cover incidents like this but even though the warranty on the roof has expired, it may be worth a try to call the roofing company and ask them to come back out to do the repairs. They may be willing since you'd already called them back out twice in such a short period of time (or at least they may discount your repairs). They may do it as a courtesy to avoid a bad reputation. Remember the squeaky wheel gets the oil.
I had my roof done two years ago for $5000. On a bungalow. The roof is to last another 25 years. I have never had to call them back and don't expect too. It is a small town. If the work was done haphazard on the OP's roof and she had to even call them back once for leakage, then they should be reported to the Better Business Bureau (if they still exist) or their equivalent. Good money is wasted and should not be.
Did they come recommended ?