Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Kohoutek's Avatar
    Kohoutek Posts: 83, Reputation: 3
    Junior Member
     
    #1

    Apr 5, 2010, 09:55 AM
    What substance would work best with a knee injury?
    Hi folks,

    I'm trying to stick to my New Year's Resolution of writing a book and I have a character in it who's an athlete with a knee injury. I want him to get drawn into taking banned substances because of his injury, but I don't know which one would make the most sense.

    I know EPO/CERA affects your red blood cell count and I know that obviously the more red blood cells you have, the more oxygen you absorb, but would somebody take CERA to give them an advantage coming back from an injury? Is there a banned substance that would make more sense in that situation? I'm thinking it'd probably be a longer course of something like testosterone?

    Basically to move the plot forward, I need a substance that would be banned in any athletic event but make sense to be taken because of an injury and not just to outright cheat. If that makes sense. :D

    Any help would be greatly appreciated, all you sport science types!
    Eileen G's Avatar
    Eileen G Posts: 1,571, Reputation: 286
    Ultra Member
     
    #2

    Apr 5, 2010, 10:21 AM

    Recovering from an injury, the most obvious would be cortisone injections into the knee, which will kill pain (though not instantly as you sometimes see on films, you have about two days of agony, then lack of pain).

    Another possibility might be Butazoladin which is certainly banned in horses because it kills pain so much a horse would jump with a broken leg on Bute.

    However, neither of them are really gateway drugs, you'd get them off a sloppy doctor.

    Your hero might use testosterone to speed up his training once the knee is stable again. T on its own won't affect knees, but it would make a big different to his ability to to explosive moves in sports. Sprinters are much more likely to use T than marathon runners.

    If you read Muscular Development magazine, there is a frequent debate about why is it legal to have operations to improve eyesight for instance in order to improve performance, but not to take supplements of naturally occurring hormones to do the same thing?
    Kohoutek's Avatar
    Kohoutek Posts: 83, Reputation: 3
    Junior Member
     
    #3

    Apr 5, 2010, 11:09 AM
    Thanks so much for your insight! :)
    It gets so confusing because I know nothing about it myself - and it's only a passing thing in the story but I don't want to get it wrong.

    Is bute illegal for use in humans? I can't see it on the WADA banned list, but then if it's not technically a drug for people, would it even be on there?

    I suppose it could work into the timeline that he was starting on a testosterone course, and knew it was illegal in his career...

    Incidentally, he's not the hero, he's the annoying thorn in her side who she has to keep bailing out. ;)

    Quote Originally Posted by Eileen G View Post
    Recovering from an injury, the most obvious would be cortisone injections into the knee, which will kill pain (though not instantly as you sometimes see on films, you have about two days of agony, then lack of pain).

    Another possibility might be Butazoladin which is certainly banned in horses because it kills pain so much a horse would jump with a broken leg on Bute.

    However, neither of them are really gateway drugs, you'd get them off a sloppy doctor.

    Your hero might use testosterone to speed up his training once the knee is stable again. T on its own won't affect knees, but it would make a big different to his ability to to explosive moves in sports. Sprinters are much more likely to use T than marathon runners.

    If you read Muscular Development magazine, there is a frequent debate about why is it legal to have operations to improve eyesight for instance in order to improve performance, but not to take supplements of naturally occurring hormones to do the same thing?
    Eileen G's Avatar
    Eileen G Posts: 1,571, Reputation: 286
    Ultra Member
     
    #4

    Apr 5, 2010, 11:23 AM

    I've been prescribed bute by a doctor, but that doesn't mean it's not on something like the Olympic list of banned drugs. There's also a question of dose as well.

    For a novel, I suppose you'd have to go with Testosterone, since it's the one everyone has heard of. I still reckon you should buy a copy of MD, just so you can get the other side of the AS debate. Not to mention technical details of what is available, and what is being faked!

    Some of the bodybuilding boards would have the same information, but if you just go looking, they'll assume you are a troll and refuse to tell you anything.

    I was in a supplement shop in Dublin recently and a guy who was clearly a cop in a tracksuit was trying to get the owner to sell him ephedrine.

    Oh, that's another possibility. Not useful as a training aid, but if he had put on weight while injured and wanted to cut to make a weight class?
    Eileen G's Avatar
    Eileen G Posts: 1,571, Reputation: 286
    Ultra Member
     
    #5

    Apr 5, 2010, 05:01 PM

    By the way, how's your book going? I've got one in the Amazon Breakthrough Novel Award, and people are getting used to me running round asking "How big a gun could you carry in a glove compartment?" and "What colour would the vegetation be on a planet with no open water?"
    Kohoutek's Avatar
    Kohoutek Posts: 83, Reputation: 3
    Junior Member
     
    #6

    Apr 6, 2010, 06:40 AM
    I might just buy a copy of MD - thanks for the heads up. Bute sounds like it would be perfect, but I guess I'd have to explain what it is and that might disrupt the pace of the story, whereas, like you say, everyone's heard of testosterone...

    I'll look up Ephedrine - it's on the WADA banned list and seems quite readily available so I'll see whether it'd fit with the plot.

    Thanks again for all your advice - it's much appreciated.

    Quote Originally Posted by Eileen G View Post
    I've been prescribed bute by a doctor, but that doesn't mean it's not on something like the Olympic list of banned drugs. There's also a question of dose as well.

    For a novel, I suppose you'd have to go with Testosterone, since it's the one everyone has heard of. I still reckon you should buy a copy of MD, just so you can get the other side of the AS debate. Not to mention technical details of what is available, and what is being faked!

    Some of the bodybuilding boards would have the same information, but if you just go looking, they'll assume you are a troll and refuse to tell you anything.

    I was in a supplement shop in Dublin recently and a guy who was clearly a cop in a tracksuit was trying to get the owner to sell him ephedrine.

    Oh, that's another possibility. Not useful as a training aid, but if he had put on weight while injured and wanted to cut to make a weight class?
    NeedKarma's Avatar
    NeedKarma Posts: 10,635, Reputation: 1706
    Uber Member
     
    #7

    Apr 6, 2010, 07:09 AM
    I thought the big name player is cortisone as a knee injection: Cortisone Steroid Injections - knee, injuries, training, strength, muscle - World of Sports Science
    Eileen G's Avatar
    Eileen G Posts: 1,571, Reputation: 286
    Ultra Member
     
    #8

    Apr 6, 2010, 10:28 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by NeedKarma View Post
    It is. But it's not a banned substance, or something that would be considered an unfair advantage.
    Eileen G's Avatar
    Eileen G Posts: 1,571, Reputation: 286
    Ultra Member
     
    #9

    Apr 6, 2010, 10:31 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by Kohoutek View Post
    I might just buy a copy of MD - thanks for the heads up. Bute sounds like it would be perfect, but I guess I'd have to explain what it is and that might disrupt the pace of the story, whereas, like you say, everyone's heard of testosterone...

    I'll look up Ephedrine - it's on the WADA banned list and seems quite readily available so I'll see whether it'd fit with the plot.

    Thanks again for all your advice - it's much appreciated.
    It would be no harm to be able to toss in a couple of names of specific drugs, just to make you sound authentic, and then just talk about "cycle" or "AS" or even "T". No-one who uses them ever talks about "roids" or anything like that.

    There are a lot of health benefits to testosterone, it's often prescribed to older men with low levels by doctors, so it's possible he could rationalise it to himself without too much spinning.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

I think I may have a serious knee injury [ 1 Answers ]

About three weeks agos I began developing a sharp pain on my left knee on the inside of it. It only hurt when walking, but when I was resting it was fine. It recently began hurting constantly though and my knee gave out a little bit once. Whenever I bend my knee there is a popping or clicking sound...

Work related injury [ 1 Answers ]

I have a work related injury. Can my employer ask about my treatment? How much can they ask? I am working with the case manager assigned to my company from the insurance company for the L & I cases. The questions were why off work for several more weeks. It and what treatment is your doctor...

Work injury! [ 3 Answers ]

I have emailed questions with regard to workmans comp in the past and I am still not sure about light duty I live in California. I have two herniated discs and just had an epidural injection for the first time about a week ago. After the epidural injections I still have mucsle spasms, and pain...

Knee injury, helping with the pain [ 4 Answers ]

Hello. I am 20 years old and when I was around 12 I had a major rock climbing accident. I lost my footing, the rocks below me gave out and I was on my way down the cliff. I snapped tendons and ligaments in my knees and have had to deal with a good amount of pain since then and I have been told by...

Knee injury healed itself .BUT! [ 1 Answers ]

I had a knee injury that I was seen at the hospital for, and the ER dr gave me a knee brace and told me to just ice the knee and if it wasn't better, then I needed to see a Orthopedic dr. However, I don't have anymore pain, but now I have this "bonelike" lump sticking out the right side of knee......


View more questions Search