Check out some similar questions!

Nestorian · Jan 17, 2009, 09:37 PM

Ok, lets keep it above the belt so gloves up, and I want clean answers boys and girls. "Don't make me destroy you!" - Darth Vader (Cool Breathing sounds..? Hehe)

(WARNING: Plot spoilers, for both harry potter and Star wars. If you haven't heard and you don't want to know, turn back must you. ;))

Ok, so I'm not sure, I've debated this for a time now and I'm stuck. I'll make clear where we are. Vader is at the point when he hassent met luke yet. So just be for A new hope, I'm not sure? Lets say 10years before the battle of Yavin, the battle Luke learns to trust his feelings and blows up the space station. (or Episod 4, a new hope.) Harry, at the end of book seven, yes I mean the very end at the train station with his kids.

PLace for the fight, hum? The forests of Mirkwood. You know in the hobbit when they are stuck in the forest an what not. Spiders and stuff. I'd prefer to see them fight during the first age when there were, dragons, Balrogs, Ungoliant, werewolves, Melkor/Morgoth, and so on.

So, who would win eh? Light saber verses wizzard wand. :)

jmerg1 · Jan 17, 2009, 11:24 PM

I think it would depend on who struck first and if it's a random incounter or toe to toe grudge match

Nestorian · Jan 18, 2009, 02:09 AM

Originally Posted by jmerg1

i think it would depend on who struck first and if its a random incounter or toe to toe grudge match

Good point, There is a bit of a clearing, you know roots of trees all over, uneven ground, small streem between them, it's about two feet wide, small. They are sent to find one another and arrive at the same time.

Vader has his force/light saber, while harry has his wand/broom stick. Personally I don't know, it's pretty much a question of what is stronger, the force, or Magic?

Magic seems to have a lot of uses, and means to manipulate environments but the force is the environment, and you.

My guess is Vader would wait for Harry to attack. Harry, probbably go for the disarming spell. Vader would definitely side step, with out effort. This is to show his supioror "power". Then he would send a rock at harry who would dodge coming up with another spell. But from there? I've no idea.

Artem · Jan 18, 2009, 02:16 AM

Darth Vader. Simply because millions of StarWars fans are at stake. Little kids would get over the Harry-looses-trauma faster than 40 year old convention-visitors.

jmerg1 · Jan 18, 2009, 02:33 AM

Well now that I think about it if vader got harry in his patentit choke hold harry could not cast any spells end of combat LOL

Curlyben · Jan 18, 2009, 02:41 AM

As the force encompasses EVERYTHING this would be no contest for Darth.
HP would get pooched in a matter of seconds ;)

The ONLY way Harry could win would be if he was snaeky and struck Darth when he wasn't looking, but as Harry's a goodie two shoes this wouldn't happen.
Darth on the other hand would have no qualms of using any underhand tactics he could, that's the main advantage of being EVIL..

Nestorian · Jan 18, 2009, 02:45 AM

Originally Posted by jmerg1

well now that i think about it if vader got harry in his patentit choke hold harry could not cast any spells end of combat LOL

That is a good point, but that's assuming that harry didn't learn, oh pitter patter what was it called when the wizzards cast spells with out words? I think they talked about it in the 5th one, the order of the Phenix. Is it Pheinix or Phenix, the first one looks better. Meh.

Could be rather interesting. Then vader would have to use force shield, to protect himself. But what spell would harry use, after all he'd be a what ever Mad-eye Moody was. Arour? Not to mention, if vader sent any force type attacks would the patronus keep him safe, I don't think it would, I think it would onlt work on sertain creatures?