[KISS]

The drip edge has a verticle section. That is available in various lenghts from 1" to maybe 6" long. It also has a fixed section that goes under the shingles and the length doesn't matter.

A drip edge is a little fancier than a 90 deg bend, but for all intents and purposes for this discusson, assume that is what it is. About 4" that goes under the shingle and some distance X that folds over the edge.

Assume X is 1". Roof thickness is 5/8" of an inch. 1" minus 5/8 = 3/8". Thus 3/8 of an inch of the drip edge extends below the edge of the roof. The top of the gutter, then buts up against this. This puts the gutter 3/8" of an inch below the bottom edge of the roof.

If that overhand was 2", the gutter would be 2" minus 5/8" or 1 and 3/8. In this case the gutter would be 1 and 3/8 of an inch below the bottom edge of the roof and that would not look good at all.

Make sense?

I'd have to measure what the stuff I used last year was.

Aside:
The tar paper or ice and water shield goes ON TOP OF the drip edge portion that goes on top of the roof.

The drip edge actually extends the roof line by about 1/4", but it mounts flush against the thichness of the plywood. It ten goes down X distance and has a small outward bend to it, so water is directed away, rather than under the roof.

[stevekem]

Got it! Thanks for the explanation. :)

The drip edge has a verticle section. That is available in various lenghts from 1" to maybe 6" long. It also has a fixed section that goes under the shingles and the length doesn't matter.

A drip edge is a little fancier than a 90 deg bend, but for all intents and purposes for this discusson, assume that is what it is. About 4" that goes under the shingle and some distance X that folds over the edge.

Assume X is 1". Roof thickness is 5/8" of an inch. 1" minus 5/8 = 3/8". Thus 3/8 of an inch of the drip edge extends below the edge of the roof. The top of the gutter, then buts up against this. This puts the gutter 3/8" of an inch below the bottom edge of the roof.

If that overhand was 2", the gutter would be 2" minus 5/8" or 1 and 3/8. In this case the gutter would be 1 and 3/8 of an inch below the bottom edge of the roof and that would not look good at all.

Make sense?

I'd have to measure what the stuff I used last year was.

Aside:
The tar paper or ice and water shield goes ON TOP OF the drip edge portion that goes on top of the roof.

The drip edge actually extends the roof line by about 1/4", but it mounts flush against the thichness of the plywood. It ten goes down X distance and has a small outward bend to it, so water is directed away, rather than under the roof.

[KISS]

OK, I decided that the only way to do this is to go and take a picture of what I did.

This is "the impossible".

Hidden hangers + seamless gutter + Ice&water + 7/8" drip edge.

No problem.

[stevekem]

Are your hangers attached behind the drip edge?

OK, I decided that the only way to do this is to go and take a picture of what I did.

This is "the impossible".

Hidden hangers + seamless gutter + Ice&water + 7/8" drip edge.

No problem.

[hkstroud]

I did an earlier post that appears to have gotten lost. I probably forgot to hit the send button.

That post basically said that no, I have not heard of a roofer doing it his way. His way seems like a lot more work. If he is willing to do it this way to protect his shingles he must be very conscientious about his work.

However, if this is the type of "hidden" hanger he is using, he needs to just do the shingles (with drip edge) and let the gutter man hang the gutters.

Don't see any conflict between the drip edge and the gutter.

[KISS]

Are your hangers attached behind the drip edge?

Not really, but the drip edge (7/8" dimension) limits the position of the gutter. 7/8" doesn't really limit it at all, but a 1.5" drip edge would.

Here is some dimensions that are large:

Open Angle Drip Edge

[stevekem]

Hey guys,

Roof was just finished and I posted a new question recently with pictures showing some possible issues. Could you possibly take a peak and give me your thoughts?

https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/exteri...cs-240932.html


Thanks in advance!