Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Mckinney300z's Avatar
    Mckinney300z Posts: 2, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Jan 2, 2007, 01:39 AM
    Auto Accident: Damage Settlement not Injury Settlement
    Hello all and thank you in advance for your kind answers.

    My Girlfriend was involved in an accident in November. Here are some key points about the event.
    1. Accident Fault - Fault was clearly the other driver Documented in the Police report.
    2. Vehicle is currently financed - In both of our names so I have a valid reason for being involved with the negotiation proceedings since it was also my property involved.
    3. This question is about dealing with the Insurance company on the Damage to the vehicle not the Personal Injury.

    We have been contacted by the other drivers insurance and they have offered a settlement. The amount is $2600.00 the total remaining balance on the vehicle note is $5300.00. The vehicle is a total loss. (passenger side door is now residing in the driver seat) The insurance company knows this and is dealing with it as so. I believe that I should be able to collect the payoff amount from the insurance company for several reasons.

    1. The accident was their clients fault
    2. Had the accident no occurred I would still have a vehicle to drive
    3. The cash value of the car may be $2600 but the damage to me is $5300
    4. The insurance company has an obligation to put me where I was before the $2600 does not put me where I was before it leaves me without a vehicle and $2500 in the hole. That is hardley putting me where I was before the accident.

    The insurance company is telling me that this is a cash value policy and they will not pay more that the $2600.00

    What would your advice be in dealing with the insurance company?
    highlyfavoredjb's Avatar
    highlyfavoredjb Posts: 9, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #2

    Jan 2, 2007, 02:10 AM
    Mckinney300Z,

    I am sorry to hear of this situation and it happens all too often. Please listen to what I am saying: the value of your vehicle is not always what is owed on your vehicle. The way it works is this, first who declared the vehicle total loss. Your insurance co. or the insurance co. of the driver that hit your vehicle? If you accept the other insurance co. total loss your co. may not see it that way. But here's how is works, you need to check the blue book on your vehicle (at post office or bank or insurance co office), look at the things you had in your vehicle i.e... cd player, wheels, pwr steering, condition of vehicle (good or okay), leather seats, etc... those kinds of things. It all adds up to tell you the value of your vehicle. Also, you can check with local dealers to see what your vehicle would sell for (sometimes it different from the blue book more or less). Something missing, what has your insurance co. said to you? Be careful of one major thing: DO NOT SIGN THE VEHICLE (DMV) PAPERWORK TO ANYONE!! Sometimes companys will say its just to clear DMV of your ownership, it is but wait until you know you have the best deal possible for YOU! And since the other vehicle did damage your vehicle they should pay it off. However, if you go to court the judge will surely tell you that you can only collect what the vehicle is worth not what you owe. I hope this helps you with your loss.

    Good luck, jill
    ScottGem's Avatar
    ScottGem Posts: 64,966, Reputation: 6056
    Computer Expert and Renaissance Man
     
    #3

    Jan 2, 2007, 08:35 AM
    First, you can go to kbb.com or edmunds.com and get a value for your vehicle. Second, you need to talk to YOUR insurance company. If they will pay off the loan, then take it and let them sue the other party's insurance co for reimbursement.

    But, they are only required to pay what their insured's policy is for. I'm not sure where you get the idea that they are supposed to make you whole. The policy would have to have been written that way. If the value of the car was only $2600, then you may be out of luck here.
    Mckinney300z's Avatar
    Mckinney300z Posts: 2, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #4

    Jan 2, 2007, 10:44 PM
    Here is some clarification
    1. The vehicle was declared a total loss by State Farm (the insurance company of the person who hit my car)

    2. My insurance company (also state farm) has not had much to do with this claim since the fault has been determined to be entirely his fault.

    3. We have not submitted anything to his insurance for what was in the vehicle. Strangely enough my girlfriend had almost $900.00 worth of make up that was destroyed. And I had some computer equipment (DVD Burner etc.) in the vehicle.

    (note on number 3: I don't know how they will react to a claim on that high of a dollar amount of make up but we have photo proof of what was destroyed and receipts for the purchase of it. Hopefully it is a good thing we are dealing with a female on the claim she should under stand that it is not hard to have $900.00 worth of make up in an everyday bag.)

    As to why she had this high dollar amount - she used to be a clineque consultant working their retail make up counter. - One small compact of powder base is $54.00
    ScottGem's Avatar
    ScottGem Posts: 64,966, Reputation: 6056
    Computer Expert and Renaissance Man
     
    #5

    Jan 3, 2007, 07:08 AM
    I think you stand a good chance of recovering the value of the goods destroyed by the accident. If you have proof of their destruction and receipts showing their value. But I don't think you will get them to cover the balance of your loan. The insured's policy is such that it will only reimburse the value of the car, not make the injured party whole.
    excon's Avatar
    excon Posts: 21,482, Reputation: 2992
    Uber Member
     
    #6

    Jan 3, 2007, 07:58 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by ScottGem
    The insured's policy is such that it will only reimburse the value of the car, not make the injured party whole.
    Hello Mac:

    Whole?? If you have a car worth $257, and the insurance company gives you $257, that looks pretty whole to me.

    What you owed isn't a factor. Why should it be? You had stuff in the car. IF they give you anything for it, it's going to be based upon the MARKET value of the stuff - just like they valued the car.

    Yup, I know, she paid $54 for some stuff. But, the stuff was used. Ok, maybe not "used", but NOT new. So, tell me, how much would the (not new) $54 stuff be worth on the table at your neighbor's yard sale? A couple bucks - maybe?? That's the value - really. That's what the insurance company should offer, and that's what you should accept.

    Let's say that you owed $476 on the stuff. Do you think the insurance company (or the court) is going to care?? Nope, they're not. Just like they're not going to care what you owed on the car.

    excon
    jgoldman77's Avatar
    jgoldman77 Posts: 3, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #7

    Jan 5, 2007, 09:02 AM
    Just a couple thoughts - I am going through a similar situation where my wife was involved in an auto accident, no injuries, other driver fully at fault, but his insurance company won't pay.

    First, note that the amount remaining on your auto loan is not necessarily the same as the vehicle's value. If a vehicle is a total loss, the at fault insurance company must give you the pre-accident value of the vehicle, which is different than paying off your loan.

    Second, though your damage is $5600 that is only something you can be given if you choose to have your vehicle repaired. Our vehicle had $7000 worth of damage, and every penny went to the repair shop. The insurance co is now trying to settle for a measly $1000. If your vehicle is a total loss, the insurance isn't going to give YOU the money that would have gone to a repair shop to fix the vehicle.

    I know, its insanely frustrating, but I hope that helps. I would suggest getting an attorney and considering bringing suit against the ins co.
    ScottGem's Avatar
    ScottGem Posts: 64,966, Reputation: 6056
    Computer Expert and Renaissance Man
     
    #8

    Jan 5, 2007, 09:21 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by jgoldman77
    Second, though your damage is $5600 that is only something you can be given if you choose to have your vehicle repaired. Our vehicle had $7000 worth of damage, and every penny went to the repair shop. The insurance co is now trying to settle for a measly $1000. If your vehicle is a total loss, the insurance isn't going to give YOU the money that would have gone to a repair shop to fix the vehicle.
    I think you are a bit mixed up here. If the vehicle is repairable, then the insurance company will pay for the repairs. If you use an affiliated repair shop, they will pay the shop directly. If you use your own shop, they will issue a check to you for THEIR estimate of the repair costs. If your shop charges more, you are left holding the bag. But if you use an affiliated or authorized shop, they will pay the difference.

    If the vehicle is considered totaled, then the insurance company will give you a check for the book value of the vehicle before the accident.
    s2tp's Avatar
    s2tp Posts: 299, Reputation: 61
    Full Member
     
    #9

    Jan 5, 2007, 09:24 AM
    I am not sure about at-fault accidents, but several months ago my car got broken into, and over $7000 worth of DVDs an CD's were stolen, along with my radio face and other vandalized items.
    My insurance Company covered all the damages to the car as long as it was attached to my car, such as by screws, glue, etc. They would not cover any items IN the vehicle.. such as all my cds and dvd's cause that stuff falls under Homeowners/renters insurance.

    I did not press the issue since this incident happened in Arizona while I was driving through. It happened at a hotel though, and I should have gone to the hotel insurance to cover my stuff... I decided it was more trouble that I didn't have time for...

    So I am not sure about State farm, but they may see the loose items as the same.

    Another thing to mention is when I bought my car I purchased GAP insurance. This insurance was my safety net so if my car DID get totaled, and I was only paid the worth of the car and not the remaining loan, this insurance would cover that remaining balance. Luckily I never had to use it, but it's a good idea when you buy a car...
    s2tp's Avatar
    s2tp Posts: 299, Reputation: 61
    Full Member
     
    #10

    Jan 5, 2007, 09:40 AM
    Quote Originally Posted by ScottGem
    I think you are a bit mixed up here. If the vehicle is repairable, then the insurance company will pay for the repairs. If you use an affiliated repair shop, they will pay the shop directly. If you use your own shop, they will issue a check to you for THEIR estimate of the repair costs. If your shop charges more, you are left holding the bag. But if you use an affiliated or authorized shop, they will pay the difference.

    If the vehicle is considered totaled, then the insurance company will give you a check for the book value of the vehicle before the accident.

    Scott,

    Actually that's not true.. at least not in my case.

    When my car was vandalized I took my car to the nearest shop and the insurance guy met me there. Progressive talked with the repair shop and issued them a check to cover the repairs. I was in Arizona driving to California where my uncle owns a auto repair shop, so when I called him he told me to just tell the repair shop that I would get my window fixed with them, but would continue the rest of the repairs when I got home so I wasn't paying out of pocket for the hotel room extra nights.

    My insurance company would not issue the check to me directly. They would only sign it to either me and the lien holder, or me and the repair shop. Previous experience taught me that trying to cash a check between you and the lien holder- they wouldn't let me, they wanted the total deposited into the remaining balance...

    Well I got the check, turned my car into my uncles shop, an he told me that he could do supplements. Meaning that if parts and labor cost more at his shop than the other shop then he would just contact the insurance company and they would send him another check to cover the difference.

    Also insurance companies give estimates on knock off parts, not manufacturer. Another thing my uncle told me is that when I had to have my bumper or hood (cant remember) replaced it would not line up right so he had to go for the higher priced part to fit better. When this happened he again went to the insurance company, showed proof that he did try the lower grade part but that it was not a proper fit... and again they sent him a check for the difference.

    I know this story differs than the original one, but I just wanted to point out that check company can and will pay the difference if need be.

    I believe you can get estimates done at different shops, and the insurance company will go for the lowest bidder... it sucks, but it's the system...
    ScottGem's Avatar
    ScottGem Posts: 64,966, Reputation: 6056
    Computer Expert and Renaissance Man
     
    #11

    Jan 5, 2007, 11:16 AM
    I suspect your uncle is an affiliated shop or it maybe he's licensed by the locality so his supplements are accepted. But there is a lot of dishonesty in the body shop industry, so its much easier to work with an authorized shop.
    sideoutshu's Avatar
    sideoutshu Posts: 225, Reputation: 23
    Full Member
     
    #12

    Jan 11, 2007, 05:10 AM
    First off, it doesn't matter how "the policy was written" for the other party. That would impact on the other party collecting from their own company, not you. You are not in a position to pick the type of insurance policy of the person who hits you. Liability coverage is mandatory because you have to be able to compensate for the value of anything you destroy as a result of your own fault.

    Now, what the value is... is a different story. I usually handle property damage claims as a courtesy to those who I am representing for personal injuries. You have a couple of avenues you can go down. It really won't pay to get an attorney as there is so little at issue.

    1. Talk to your own insurance company regarding the value of your vehicle. Usually in instances where there is shared fault, insurance companies will negotiate between themselves to determine the appropriate payout. Talking to your agent can't hurt.

    2. Look into the possibility of arbitration. Ask the insurance company to send you the offer in writing, and the documents they send you will usually include provisions for arbitration if you can't come to an agreement. It may be different across different states, but it may be as simple as filling out a form they send to you. Once you get before an arbitrator, you will present evidence as to what you believe the value of the car was. If the documents don't provide for same, ask for a COMPLETE copy of the policy uder which payment is being offered.

    Probably the easiest thing to do, is just straight out ask the adjuster over the phone "what do I do if I don't agree with your assessment". They will probably tell you what the exact procedure is.
    s_cianci's Avatar
    s_cianci Posts: 5,472, Reputation: 760
    Uber Member
     
    #13

    Jan 11, 2007, 07:23 PM
    Since the vehicle is totaled, the insurance company should be paying you the book value of the car, which does not necessarily equal the payoff balance. If the other driver's coverage is limited, then you can try to recover the difference from your own insurance (protection against uninsured/underinsured drivers) or directly from the other driver.
    kdakak's Avatar
    kdakak Posts: 1, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #14

    Mar 18, 2007, 07:15 PM
    Quote Originally Posted by Mckinney300z
    Hello all and thank you in advance for your kind answers.

    My Girlfriend was involved in an accident in November. Here are some key points about the event.
    1. Accident Fault - Fault was clearly the other driver Documented in the Police report.
    2. Vehicle is currently financed - In both of our names so I have a valid reason for being involved with the negotiation proceedings since it was also my property involved.
    3. This question is about dealing with the Insurance company on the Damage to the vehicle not the Personal Injury.

    We have been contacted by the other drivers insurance and they have offered a settlement. The amount is $2600.00 the total remaining balance on the vehicle note is $5300.00. The vehicle is a total loss. (passenger side door is now residing in the driver seat) The insurance company knows this and is dealing with it as so. I believe that I should be able to collect the payoff amount from the insurance company for several reasons.

    1. The accident was their clients fault
    2. Had the accident no occurred I would still have a vehicle to drive
    3. The cash value of the car may be $2600 but the damage to me is $5300
    4. The insurance company has an obligation to put me where I was before the $2600 does not put me where I was before it leaves me without a vehicle and $2500 in the hole. That is hardley putting me where I was before the accident.

    The insurance company is telling me that this is a cash value policy and they will not pay more that the $2600.00

    What would your advice be in dealing with the insurance company?
    The insurance co will only pay you what your car was worth just before the accident.Most companies will offer the least amount for a total loss.If you believe that your car is worth more than get an independent licensed arbitrator to come up with an amount.Then present that to the insurance co.If they refuse than invoke the arbitration procedure.
    Also did you suffer loss of earnings, rental car expense? If you did not rent a car than claim loss of use allowance of $20.00 per day.
    Do not cash any checks nor sign the title till you settle on the amounts in writing.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Car accident settlement [ 8 Answers ]

Hello I'm about to reach a settlement with an auto insurance regarding a car accident that I was involved last month, I'm of course going to try to bleach their bones, because I know they will try to offer me a disgusting amount. At this time I am not taking an attorney with me, if I see that...

Settlement [ 1 Answers ]

My husband is getting a settlement from a pharmisuitcal company. He is on S.S.D. He is not good with handling money,so he wants to sign the check over to me. I will than deposit to my account. MY question is this, This settlement was granted to him because he almost died from medication. This money...

Settlement? [ 2 Answers ]

I recently totaled out a new car... don't have any idea why we didn't have gap... Anyway, I owe after insurance about $9500.00. Our credit is reasonable about 630... I have offered a settlement amount of $8200. They said that the credit report will reflect that: settlement: paid in full. ...

Car Accident Settlement [ 3 Answers ]

I was in a car accident and in May 14, 2006 will be the limit to file. I've been working with the insurance company and they want to settle for 13,500. $6,762.75 in what they claim are medical cost and 6,500.00 for my pain and suffering. My medical cost comes out to 14,000, milage @1,095.26. I...

Accident settlement [ 3 Answers ]

What should I take into consideration when accepting a settlement from an auto accident? I do not have an attorney. I received medical treatment(therapy, etc.).


View more questions Search