Ask Me Help Desk

Ask Me Help Desk (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forum.php)
-   Home Schooling (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=159)
-   -   452xy/60 then (x+y)=? (https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/showthread.php?t=811813)

  • May 14, 2015, 09:00 PM
    rajzxc
    452xy/60 then (x+y)=?
    if the number 452xy be completely divisible by 60, the value of (x+y) is ?
    options are :-
    1)8
    2)6
    3)3
    4)1
    5) none of these


    according to my answer sheet the answer is 4th option that is 1, but i am not satisfy.
    ... *... *...

    my opinion:-
    60 = 6*10
    then last digit of 452xy is 0 it means y is 0. then x must be a number by that 452xy completely divisible by 60. I think x will be 4. so (x+y)= (4+0)= 4
    Answer is 5th option None of these.
  • May 15, 2015, 06:13 AM
    ebaines
    You seem to be thinking that the question is about the number that is equal to 452x100+10x+y, but as written I think it's about the number 452 times x times y. Please clarify which it is! If the former, then you are correct: 45240 is divisible by 60, so x+y = 4. But I'm thinking they want the latter.

    The solution hinges on whether you consider the number 0 to be "completely divisible" by 60. When you divide 0 by 60 it leaves no remainder, so I think xy=0 is a possible solution. Suppose x = 0, then y can be any value imaginable, and thus x+y can be anything, and so all choices given are possible.

    But i would guess that your teacher isn't expecting a solution based on xy = 0, or else there would be an "all the the above" choice. So let's try another approach. Since 452 = 4 x 113, then since 452xy is divisible by 60 this means (4 x 113)xy is divisible by 60. Since 113 is prime, it has no common factors with 60. Thus 4xy must be divisible by 60. Divide through by 4: xy must be divisible by 15. Thus xy=15N, where N is some integer. We've already seen what happens if N=0, so let's try N=1: this means xy equals 15, so xy must be either 1 x 15 or 3 x 5, which means the sum is either 16 or 8. Thus the first answer choice (8) is a possibility. If N=2 then xy = 30 and x+y could be 1+30=31 or 2+15=17 or 3+10=13 or 5+6 = 11. None of these are given as choices. It's pretty easy to show that for greater values of N the sum x+y will always be greater than 11, so none of the other given choices are possible. I would therefore say that of the choices given x+y=8 is the answer they're looking for.

  • All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:07 AM.