Originally Posted by wildandblue
a lot of questions about your post. You have roof problems now, so stop worrying if you will have them later. A roof has no memory. If you fix it and fix it right there will be no further problems. However I need a lot more information. Is the broken rafter a 2x4? This is way undersized. Any explanation as to how it got broken? Did a tree limb fall on roof? Was it damaged from a heavy snow load or an ice dam? Is there insulation up there right under the roof or is it on the floor of the attic? Is the attic floor finished or do you have access to the floor joists? This kind of damage on a fairly new house is a big red flag. If he didn't maintain the roof or fix the break or the leak he probably neglected a lot of other important stuff too. You would be absolutely right to lower your bid or just reconsider getting involved with this house. Basically You want a 2x6 rafter 16" on center at the absolute minimum and covered by 3/4" of exterior CDX plywood. You would start from the low point, brace the roof boards, use a jack between the floor joist and this brace to raise everything back up level and then slip a new rafter underneath and tie into the wall plate and ridgeplate before removing the jack. Then you can cut out the old broken one. Then you got to patch the roof from the outside, all this moving around will have disturbed the shingles.