The first one:- file:///C:/Users/Insha/Pictures/Fated%20Feelings/Images/Cover/Fated%20Feelings%201.png

C:\Users\Insha\Pictures\Fated Feelings\Images\Cover\Picture1.jpg

I've made these two and uh I'm having a hard time deciding whether I like the first one.

We can't view the pictures.

46197
46196

Oops sorry, here they are.

The first one you have listed here, 46197, is nicer but the font needs to be re-done. It looks like you stretched it or the dpi is off.