PDA

View Full Version : Is the film who shot Liberty Valance an example of Hobbes or Lokean point of view?


TeamEdwardJace
Jan 14, 2013, 02:15 PM
Or both? I think it may be both. Could you tell what you think and provide examples from movie (with their aruguments)?


Thanks

Wondergirl
Jan 14, 2013, 02:17 PM
Is this homework?

TeamEdwardJace
Jan 15, 2013, 10:37 AM
Is this homework?


It would help me when I have to write a philosophy paper

Cat1864
Jan 15, 2013, 11:50 AM
it would help me when i have to write a philosophy paper

So, yes, this is school work related?

For those who aren't looking at Philosophy text books, why don't you explain your question in a bit more detail and back up your opinion. You are the one who is writing the paper.

Remember we ask that you show your work. 'I think it may be both' doesn't begin to show how much thought and effort you have put into the question.

Wondergirl
Jan 15, 2013, 12:10 PM
Hint: Yes, it's both. Clue word: greed.

Describe Liberty's greed and how it ties in with Locke's and Hobbes' philosophies (which you will also describe, as they fit in with the movie and Liberty).

TeamEdwardJace
Jan 25, 2013, 09:13 AM
This? I'm taking a movies and morality class in college where we examine movies with morals. Anyway, this was for social contract theory and the discussed theorists are Hobbes and John Locke. Can someone please help me? Which view do you think it supports the most? I think that there's a possibly for both as there are characters and elements in the movie that would support both views.


If possible, can someone please tell me what the movie most supports with examples? And which arguments of these philosophers would be This would possibly help me with some assignments.

Wondergirl
Jan 25, 2013, 09:20 AM
When you posted this the first time, I Googled your question and found all sorts of helps regarding the movie and Locke/Hobbs. No one here will do your homework for you. I might be nice enough to give you one link if you are totally desperate, but it is all there spread out like a picnic feast if you Google with appropriate keywords.

OF COURSE, you won't plagiarize.

TeamEdwardJace
Jan 29, 2013, 04:01 PM
When you posted this the first time, I Googled your question and found all sorts of helps regarding the movie and Locke/Hobbs. No one here will do your homework for you. I might be nice enough to give you one link if you are totally desperate, but it is all there spread out like a picnic feast if you Google with appropriate keywords.

OF COURSE, you won't plagiarize.

Hey I understand that no one is going to my homework and there's a link. I have my own theories but there may some possible points that I am missing. What key words did you use? Also , I would not copy of the but they may help me consider some points I am missing to help me properly formulate an argument for an assignment

Wondergirl
Jan 29, 2013, 04:16 PM
what key words did you use?
Keywords would be the obvious ones. I used Google.