riyaspmd
Feb 20, 2012, 08:38 AM
Dear sir,assalamu alaikum
My name is riyas mohammed I am an indian working as engineer in oman,
My cousin mr. Sabri harid send me mail as shown below trying to prove that hadith is not required to follow islam, I know that he is not correct but I am not able to give convincing replay to correct his thoughts, please give some convincing answer to his letter so that I can forward to him and make him understand
Hope you will help me in this matter
May god bless you
Riyas
Subject: Asalamualikum... r we on the right path... from the Quran
Asalmualikum...
Some findings I wanted to share...
Shall we believe God and His Final Prophet? Or, shall we believe the "Muslim Scholars"?
These are God's revelations that we recite to you, bearing the truth. Which Hadith, beside God and His revelations do they believe in? 45:6
Proclaim (0 Muhammad), "What better witness do
You want?" Say, "God Is the witness between me and you, that THIS QURAN was given to me to deliver to you and to the future generations. 6:19
Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He sent down to you this book FULLY DETAILED? 6: 114
You shall remind-with the Quran-those who reverence My promise. 50:45
(He did not say "with the Quran & Hadith")
When you read the Quran, we place
Between you and those who do not believe in the Hereafter an invisible
Barrier .... And when you preach your Lord, using the QURAN ALONE, they run away in aversion. 17:45-46
There are those who use vain Hadith to mislead the people, who possess no knowledge. 31:6
(On the Day of Judgment) the Messenger will say, "My Lord, my people have deserted this Quran." 25:30(He did no say "Quran and Sunna."]
Let us look at "the most authentic Hadith;" one that was supposedly
Witnessed by 100,000 companions of the Prophet. These 100,000 people
Included Abu Bakr, Omar, Uthmaan, Ali, and the rest. While other
Hadiths were witnessed by only a few people, this one famous Hadith was witnessed by all the Muslims. It is the Prophet's Hadith of the famous "Khutbat Al-Wadaa` " (The Farewell Sermon). We have three different
"authentic" versions of this famous Hadith.
1] According to the Muwatta', one of the most respected sources of authentic Hadith, the Prophet said at Khutbat Al Wadaa`:
I am leaving for you two things that you must uphold strongly; the Quran and my Sunnah.
[2] According to Muslim (44/4, No. 2408), a very respected
Source of Hadith, and Ibn Hanbal (4/366), even more respected, the
Prophet said at Khutbat Al-Wadaa, as witnessed by 100,000 companions:
I am leaving for you two things that you must uphold strongly; the Quran ands my family.
[3]According to Muslim (15/19, No. 1218) and Ibn Majah (25/84, #3074), very very respected sources, what the Prophet really said was:
I am leaving for you the Quran -- only the Quran. You shall uphold it strongly.
There you have it. Now, what did the Prophet really say? The Quran, the whole Quran, and nothing but the Quran.
Please correct me if I'm wrong
Thanks
Regards & Best
My name is riyas mohammed I am an indian working as engineer in oman,
My cousin mr. Sabri harid send me mail as shown below trying to prove that hadith is not required to follow islam, I know that he is not correct but I am not able to give convincing replay to correct his thoughts, please give some convincing answer to his letter so that I can forward to him and make him understand
Hope you will help me in this matter
May god bless you
Riyas
Subject: Asalamualikum... r we on the right path... from the Quran
Asalmualikum...
Some findings I wanted to share...
Shall we believe God and His Final Prophet? Or, shall we believe the "Muslim Scholars"?
These are God's revelations that we recite to you, bearing the truth. Which Hadith, beside God and His revelations do they believe in? 45:6
Proclaim (0 Muhammad), "What better witness do
You want?" Say, "God Is the witness between me and you, that THIS QURAN was given to me to deliver to you and to the future generations. 6:19
Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He sent down to you this book FULLY DETAILED? 6: 114
You shall remind-with the Quran-those who reverence My promise. 50:45
(He did not say "with the Quran & Hadith")
When you read the Quran, we place
Between you and those who do not believe in the Hereafter an invisible
Barrier .... And when you preach your Lord, using the QURAN ALONE, they run away in aversion. 17:45-46
There are those who use vain Hadith to mislead the people, who possess no knowledge. 31:6
(On the Day of Judgment) the Messenger will say, "My Lord, my people have deserted this Quran." 25:30(He did no say "Quran and Sunna."]
Let us look at "the most authentic Hadith;" one that was supposedly
Witnessed by 100,000 companions of the Prophet. These 100,000 people
Included Abu Bakr, Omar, Uthmaan, Ali, and the rest. While other
Hadiths were witnessed by only a few people, this one famous Hadith was witnessed by all the Muslims. It is the Prophet's Hadith of the famous "Khutbat Al-Wadaa` " (The Farewell Sermon). We have three different
"authentic" versions of this famous Hadith.
1] According to the Muwatta', one of the most respected sources of authentic Hadith, the Prophet said at Khutbat Al Wadaa`:
I am leaving for you two things that you must uphold strongly; the Quran and my Sunnah.
[2] According to Muslim (44/4, No. 2408), a very respected
Source of Hadith, and Ibn Hanbal (4/366), even more respected, the
Prophet said at Khutbat Al-Wadaa, as witnessed by 100,000 companions:
I am leaving for you two things that you must uphold strongly; the Quran ands my family.
[3]According to Muslim (15/19, No. 1218) and Ibn Majah (25/84, #3074), very very respected sources, what the Prophet really said was:
I am leaving for you the Quran -- only the Quran. You shall uphold it strongly.
There you have it. Now, what did the Prophet really say? The Quran, the whole Quran, and nothing but the Quran.
Please correct me if I'm wrong
Thanks
Regards & Best