View Full Version : Early Withdrawal on 401K
 
 Emilybach
Jul 13, 2010, 04:54 PM
I am changing jobs and I was wondering if I should cash out my 401k.  I know about all the penalties involved.  I have $6000.00 in my job sponsored 401k and I was wondering how much I will get of that $6000.00 after the taxes and penalties.  I have over $5000.00 in credit card debt and whatever I get back will go to that.   I normally wouldn't think about cashing a 401k out but I will now be driving 120 miles a day until I move, and reducing my debt will be a big help in lowering my minimum payment each month.   
 
 
Thank you
 AtlantaTaxExpert
Jul 14, 2010, 07:36 AM
Emily:
 
Transfer the 401K to a rollover IRA and forget about cashing out the 401K.  The taxes and penalties are so bad that you could pay 40% annual interest on the credit card and STILL come out ahead over doing the cash-in of the 401K.
 Emilybach
Jul 21, 2010, 12:37 PM
Okay, Thank you for answering, but I was also wondering about how much would I get out of it if I did cash it out.  Any help would be appreciated.   Thank You
 AtlantaTaxExpert
Jul 21, 2010, 01:16 PM
To adequately answer the question, I would need to know how much your annual income was (from all soucres, not just your salary).
 Emilybach
Aug 3, 2010, 06:55 PM
Here is some more information
Current Balance:	 $6,446.17	
Vested Balance:	 $5,981.79
Personal Rate of Return*:	-10.26%
Pre-Tax Contribution Rate	 10.00%		 
 
 
And my income was:  $19,422.63
 AtlantaTaxExpert
Aug 4, 2010, 10:42 AM
Assuming you get the current balance, the 10% Early Withdrawal Penalty will be $645.  
 
That penalty CANNOT be mitigated, which means that if deductions and exemptions completely offset the rest of the taxes, you will STILL pay $645.
 
Your actual tax on the $6,446 will be $968, so your total tax for the withdrawal is $1,613.
 
This does NOT include STATE income taxes on the early withdrawal.