View Full Version : 3-phase vs single phase power usage
 
 jstrange
Jun 30, 2010, 04:06 PM
My currnet a/c is on 3-phase and I'm going to replace it.  I want to get a 5 ton 16 SEER ($1500 gov't rebate)but they are available in only single phase. I'm wondering if it will cost significantly more to run a new 16 SEER unit on single phase than a new 13 SEER on 3-phase.
 KISS
Jun 30, 2010, 05:12 PM
Cost in terms of operation, no.  5HP single phase is also 5 HP 3 phase.
 
SEER takes into account the conversion of electrical energy to cooling, meaning power to cool.
 
Installation of 3 phase is mixed.  Wire costs less.  Breakers have to be larger for single phase and smaller, but with an extra one for 3 phase.  The conduit may or may not have to be re-sized.  Wires would have to be larger.
 
3 phase power loss protection is usually added. 
 
Three phase is much more reliable.  There is also less power spiking.
 
A 3 phase motor is usually more efficient, but your considering the system.
 
 
A 3 phase power has better starting torque.
 KISS
Jul 1, 2010, 04:36 PM
If yo were comparing HP to HP on single and 3 phase, the 3 phase system would be more efficient and cost less to run.
 
Since your comparing SEER, efficiencies of the various parts are taken into account.
 
The real difference is that 3 phase is more reliable and may or may not cost more to install.
 
We don't get notified with Agree/disagrees.