So I'll start with the basics.

She's almost 19, I just turned 19 a bitago. We both have our associate degrees completed and she's finishing up her BA at a University. We've been together for basically three years. I sort of saw this happening. We talked yesterday and she told me she wanted a break for a few reasons.

1)Her mom was sort of a psycho and made a lot of things tough for her. She didn't really run her own life, so she wants to be independent and make her own decisions and support herself.

2)She told me she's 90 percent there completley in love with me and can see herself spending the rest of her life with me, but that I'm her first boyfriend ever and she just wants to maybe date just to experience it. She said once again how much she loved me, and that she knew she wouldn't find someone else as good, just wanted to date for the experience of doing it.

3)We're doing this break for three months, which is the end of the quarter. She wants to experience college life- hanging out with roommates, getting used to her schedule, going out on weekends, making male friends, maybe dating. She's not the type that would go binge drink or something and sleep around.

I get all of this and all of the reasons make sense. She sees two as the final step to getting her to fully committ to this relationship 100 percent. It sucks being her only boyfriend ever, but I understand wanting to date for a few months and meet other people to confirm her own feelings. Currently, we're still friends, we talked today, and next weekend, we're taking a weekend trip across the state for a bike ride we're doing and we're going to continue to be friends. We broke up a year ago so she could sort of see what it was like to date other guys, but lots of things happened in that time with her family and such so it didn't work out like that and we basically took a break for 5 or 6 months before we basically started going out again, so I sort of know what I'm getting myself in to. I've been in a few logner relationships, and this girl is definitely one I want to spend my life with. She's gone with me two years to Michigan to meet my family and I went all out this summer on fun things and romantic things. I guess I'm just trying to figure out what to do in the next few months until we sit down and talk in December. I got a job offer up by where she's going to school, so I moved out of my parents up here a week ago. Lastnight, I was devastated and wanting to get out, I drove 3hrs home only to not want to be there after 10 min and drove back. Now I've woken up and really don't want to be here. I'm in a tailspin trying to figure out what to do the next few days until I get an idea of what to do. We'll still be hanging out once or twice a week, just need to figure out what's good for me th enext few days. Sorry for the length and any typos, in a hurry, thanks!

This isn't actually advice for you, but I thought it was worth mentioning.

I currently know/am friends with two different couples for whom their relationship is the only one they've ever been in. And ten or more years later, there have been issues and doubts and questions, and I'm not sure they are so happy.

I'm a firm believer in dating at least 2 people before getting married! I'm sure there are situations where people have married their first boyfriend and been completely happy, but I'm just going off what I know.

But, since you have started a new job, could you meet some new friends at work? Hanging out with co-workers would be an easy way to fill your time. Do you have any friends, besides her, in your current town?

I totally agree it's good for her to do this stuff. I want her to date others,see what its like, so she can make that final leap into being completely 100 percent in love with me and not having curiosity later on. I haven't started the job yet, and don't until November or early December, which sucks. So co-workers is sort of out of the question, I live out of town 10 miles on the countryside, so I'm not in town as much. Going home lastnight, I figured at least one or two of my friends would be around, but none were. I'm definitely trying to hang out with them though.

**Excuse the harshness up front!

I am sorry but I don't buy into all this BS. Date to just experience other people? You actually buy into that? Look, regardless, you go do your thing and live your life, leaving her alone. To say that one has to experience other people, dating wise, to prove their love for you is absolute garbage. PERIOD! Reality hits you and you will understand that feelings are feelings and they don't need to be validated. Love is love, that's it. They shouldn't need to be confirmed. You do what you want, but if someone fed me this line of BS, I would be gone. Just my opinion.

Love and relationships aren't scripted. You don't just put a time limit and say, "Hey, I am going to date others for the next three months just to make sure I like you. At the end of the quarter, we can get back together." That is not reality no matter which way you slice it. I am not going to be a fall back guy for any woman, nor should you.

It's completely crappy, but seeing as I am her only boyfriend ever and we've been together for this long, I understand she has the small piece of her wanting to see what it's like and experience just dating before she commits.

Commitment is about wanting, about dedication and about true passion to do something and has NOTHING to do with experience.

Let me put it to you this way: If she had stated you are the only person she has had sex with, but she wanted to have sex with other guys to make sure your sex was the right thing for her, would you still agree or understand?

I am not trying to be harsh by any means, but I have strong feeling when it comes to lines fed to boyfriends about taking a "break."

Yeah, but different kinds of commitment. When it's committing to someone in a relationship, you want to make sure your ready. What'sbetter? Having her ignore things now and continue the path and then in a year or two when maybe I'd want to propose, she decides she wants to do this before committing to engagement or something or having her do a 3 month break now to get any of that out of the way or let me know what she wants. I'd rather take that now then having her be curious later.

**Excuse the harshness up front!



Love and relationships aren't scripted. You don't just put a time limit and say, "Hey, I am going to date others for the next three months just to make sure I like you. At the end of the quarter, we can get back together." That is not reality no matter which way you slice it. I am not going to be a fall back guy for any woman, nor should you.

And I agree with that. At the end of the quarter, we're going to re-assess things and see where she's at and how she's feeling and go from there. I'm not going to be a fall back guy either, but I'm not going to give up because I really love her and it's not un normal for people to do this before they get married or commit to someone in another way. It's to get the curiosity out of the way. I'm willing to put up with giving her some space for the next few months and talka about things in December. I definitely think though by December, she needs to know one way or the other and that's the point where I stop compromising I think.

KC: I agree that taking breaks is an odd concept, a lot of the time probably BS. I've never experienced a "break taking" in one of my relationships. I do think a lot of the time it is code for just breaking up all together, but one person is too chicken to just say it.

But, I still stand behind my comment about dating/being with only one person forever. In the 2 couples I know, their relationships aren't as strong as others I've seen. But obviously this will vary from case to case.

It's not un-normal? I have NEVER heard of a couple breaking up (if indeed they are madly in love with each other) with the specific purpose of dating other people. I have been in love and when I am in LOVE, I have no curiosity about other women because all of my attention is focused on my partner.

Let me put it to you this way: If she had stated you are the only person she has had sex with, but she wanted to have sex with other guys to make sure your sex was the right thing for her, would you still agree or understand?



No, of course not. These are two totally different things.

That's BS and you are getting used like a fool. It's actually the best situation for her, she can date around and see other guys while you wait. So if it doesn't work with other guys she will come back to you, but if things happen with other guys (most probably) she will stay with them and not come back to you.

I guess you need to grow some and end that relationship already. I've been in your shoes, 3 year relationship and then a breakup, she wanted "time". Move on, this is going to end badly if you don't end it now.

KC: I agree that taking breaks is an odd concept, a lot of the time probably BS. I've never experienced a "break taking" in one of my relationships. I do think a lot of the time it is code for just breaking up all together, but one person is too chicken to just say it.

But, I still stand behind my comment about dating/being with only one person forever. In the 2 couples I know, their relationships aren't as strong as others I've seen. But obviously this will vary from case to case.

I agree a lot of it is BS, but I know from the last time we broke up she has the guts to come out and say it and be honest about it.

So if it doesn't work with other guys she will come back to you, but if things happen with other guys (most probably) she will stay with them and not come back to you.



That's the thing- She told me she doesn't want to be in a relationship for a few months because since she's been in HS, she's been in a relationship the whole time and wants to see what its like to be single and just casually date and make male friends. Since we'll still be hanging out and friends, I can judge for myself if it gets to a point where it becomes clear nothings going to happen and go back to how they were. I'm not blind, nor dumb. I'm just willing to do a lot because I've put way too much time and effort in the last 3 years to just give up.

So during this break, she will potentially be dating other men? And will you be dating other women?

So during this break, she will potentially be dating other men? And will you be dating other women?

Yeah, she'll potentially be dating other guys casually, not relationships. May sound dumb, but I don't plan to. I have no desire to, I've been in a few longer relationships already, I know what I want and I have no interest in casual dating because its just that-short term relationships to me.

That's the thing- She told me she doesn't want to be in a relationship for a few months because since she's been in HS, she's been in a relationship the whole time and wnats to see what its like to be single and just casually date and make male friends.

Translation: I want to be able to go do anything I want, with any guy I want, without having to answer to a boyfriend.


I'm just willing to do alot because i've put way too much time and effort in the last 3 years to just give up.

This isn't about giving up, it is about protecting yourself and keeping your dignity. That is our entire point.

Translation: I want to be able to go do anything I want, with any guy I want, without having to answer to a boyfriend.



This isn't about giving up, it is about protecting yourself and keeping your dignity. That is our entire point.


1) I know that's the translation. Be single and date casually and not worry about hurting me or anything. She wants to be independent and experienceit. Whatever.

2) In experience of going through this somewhat once before for some different reasons, and talking with some close friends who know me and us, it'll hurt more for me to just give up and move on then to keep myself busy and wait until then. I know what I'm getting myself into, I know the consequences. But I'd rather deal with that then just move on and forget. I don't think she's bsing and I really do believe her. If I thought she was BS'ing, I'd say F it and forget about it.

All I am saying is that if I were in your shoes, she wouldn't be the only one going off and having fun... life is too short to wait around. Just because she is going to be "free" doesn't mean you can't enjoy your time either. I just hope you aren't going to sit around and worry about her all the time, that's all.

All I am saying is that if I were in your shoes, she wouldn't be the only one going off and having fun...life is too short to wait around. Just because she is going to be "free" doesn't mean you can't enjoy your time either. I just hope you aren't going to sit around and worry about her all the time, that's all.

I plan to stay busy with hobbies and friends, just not the person that really wants to go date others.

I don't want to sound too harsh here or too insensitive, but I've been in your shoes and the same situation as you have. In the end of the day, if she truly loves you she would have stayed with you. She may love you, but she isn't in love with you anymore.

You are putting yourself in a horrid situation and you aren't able to see it. Actually it will hurt you less if you let go now then if you tried your luck. She IS going to find someone, and then the excitement of a new relationship is going to kick in. I mean why would she stay with you after 3 years when she could have any guys out there that is new and fresh.

There is a lot of difference between what many girls say and what they do. I trusted my ex, until I learned she cheated on me. She then told me she was going to wait for me to come back from a trip and she went with someone else. I was with her for 3 years.

Use your brain and don't use your feelings. Read all the threads and your situation is so similar with many other guys, "she is confused", "she doesn't know what she wants", "she only wants a break". We have all been there and we passed through the pain so that we can tell people like you not to do the same mistakes.

If you want to put your life on hold in the hope she will be yours forever, go ahead. But don't be mad if her feelings do change, and she likes her new found freedom, but still is not ready for the forever thing as you are. Is she worth the risk?

Take it from me... she is done with you- not to sound harsh but I've been there/done that. She may have already found someone. DO NOT waste your time with her- see how much she really loves you and start the no contact rule. If she trly loved you she would not be kicking you to the curb! Like everyone else said she will find someone else and you'll end up much more hurt and confused.

Let me see:

1. You are both 19.
2. You have been together for 3 years.
3. That means you first started dating at age 16.
4. When did you have time to experience "longer relationships"?
5. You broke up before? How many times? For how long? Have the causes been taken care of or have they been ignored?
6. If she came out and said, "It's over," how would you react?

It sounds like there is more to this than "I want to experience..."

I have to agree with others, that you should take this as you're through, and start moving on. If she comes back to you, then fine but don't count on it. That doesn't mean that you have to go out and start dating people, just keep busy with yourself and friends like you say you plan on doing. I personally would not be OK with what seems like renting out my girlfriend / potential wife out to other guys. I think about it logically... if I am so in love with somebody, I am not thinking about anybody else, or if I am "missing out" on anything. My partner should be everything that I need. Just my two cents.

I actually got dumped once with the lines " If you love something let it go...........", and once, " take a second look later", and even, "if its meant to be............", none of them ever came back, they moved on! So,

Talaniman Rule- When you get dumped for whatever reason, have the courtesy to leave, and do your own thing. You are single and free, whether you like it, or NOT

My point is she will be a different person when you next see her. So will you. Act accordingly.

Have you ever had one of your many conquests come back Tal?

I disappear, and heal, rather easily, at least after I learned not to fall to deep, or to fast, after all, it was during the dating years. Once I got married though, I have been rather busy just paying attention, and focusing on what's in front of me.

Most people, once they heal, just move on, and don't want to go back. That's why healing through NO CONTACT, is so important.

Only then can you make better decisions for yourself, based on facts, and not just feelings, which have been hurt. I think you deal with exes, and all situations better when you are under control of your feelings, and they don't CONTROL you.

Just came across this post this morning, and its an excellent read.

https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/relationships/first-love-story-revisited-399345.html

I agree its crappy and thinking of it in the sense of well if you'r ehappy, there should be no need to explore. But I also know some couples here, including my own sister who did that before they got married or engaged. Yes, they're incredibly happy, but there's that small part of them that needs this before they can move to the next level. I know it's a 50/50 thing and sometimes it never works again or whatever, but also knowing how it has, I'm giving it a shot. When we reassess things in a few months, I don't know if I should impose a decision deadline or what. Part of me wants to tell her she needs to decide at that point which it is, but others tell me not to. Blah.

Let me see:

1. You are both 19.
2. You have been together for 3 years.
3. That means you first started dating at age 16.
4. When did you have time to experience "longer relationships"?
5. You broke up before? How many times? For how long? Have the causes been taken care of or have they been ignored?
6. If she came out and said, "It's over," how would you react?

It sounds like there is more to this than "I want to experience..."

1)Yes
2)Yes
3)Yes
4) I dated a girl for just under a year when I was 15.
5)We broke up once, last year. It was for somewhat the same reason in some ways, she loved me but felt guilty that a small part of her wanted to see what it was like to be with someone else since we had been together since early hs and I'm her only boyfriend. During that time though, a lot of stuff went bad with her and she basically stayed at home pretty much for the few months because her mom had a brain tumor,etc, so she never really had time or wasn't a priority to find that experience. After 4 months or so, we started hanging out a bunch more and basically started going out again, just not officially or whatever. Since then, things have been amazing, took some roadtrips this summer, went on another vacation, lots of new stuff. So the causes haven't been taken care of really. I guess I just was wanting her back. This time, I still want her back, even more, so I'm willing to wait the couple months until we reassess our break, but I'll make sure she figured out what she needed to this time, because I won't go through this again.

6)I'd be pissed and probably just end things completley. Usually haven't done too well as friends after a relationship, but she and I managed to do it pretty well after a week or two. We're doing the same thing now. We already had some plans coming up, so we'll be starting the friends thing here soon. But yeah, if she said it was over, I'd say it and I know I would then be as pissed as maybe some people think I should be now.

All we can do is give you our thoughts and opinions and get you to think about questoins that you might not have asked yourself. It is up to you to make the final decision.

I personally think you need to look at your earlier break-ups and make sure that those issues aren't a part of her wanting to "explore".

I am wondering if this is her way of distancing herself from the relationship.

That's the thing, the one breakup we had was for similar reasons, but then lots of things went wrong with her life- mom tumor, parents started to get a divorce, so she never really got what she was wanting then. So I'm making sure this time around she does, and if not, I'm not saying OK, lets get back together because I won't go through this all again. She has the guts to just tell me we're breaking up and she isn't like a lot of girls who either say a break as a way to just leave, or don't have the guts to dump you. She's sometimes brutally honest and since we broke up a year ago, I know she'll tell me and has no problem. And I told her yesterday that if that was why she was doing it, she needed to tell me. So I don't think that is what it is.

If dealing with pressures in her life leads to a break up, that's something you must consider. Not saying she won't come back, and I myself have seen couples reunited, and be very happy, when the resolve their issues, and define the boundaries of good behavior together, and that includes good old fashion communications.

You don't, as yet, have that mutual commitment that defines long term couples, your still, both of you, growing, and learning, about yourselves right now. That's obvious, as you are not willing to make the adjustment necessary, for long term commitments (you may be ready, but she is NOT).

I just think your better served getting your own feelings in order, so when the time comes, you can make a decision based on facts, and not just feelings.

Its not that it can't work out, just be healthy, when the opportunity arises to give it a chance.

In life anything can happen, how you handle it, good, or bad, is what will count the most.

Decisions, decisions, that's what life is all about.

Good advice. I just feel like we're really close to that point from how this year has been and hoping this is the last hurdle. That's my hope. Of course, all of this advice helps and has brought up a few things, but I know what I want, I know this is the last time I'll go through somethjing like this with her, so she has to have it figured out this time or it's done. I don't want to sound like I think I'm better or something, but I feel like I've matured a bit faster than some of my friends, some people my age. My career I have, a lot of the life experiences I've gone through, and some of my values are different. I've learned a ton about myself, I know what I want in life, and I feel like I sped up the process for myself a bit. My one big outlying question is do I tell her come December when we officially reassess things and talk about our relationship, that I need to know then or soon after what she wants? As said before, I don't want to pressure her, because I'm willing to sacrifice some things to make this work, but I can't sacrifice all my feelings and emotions, so it's got to stop at some point. I guess I feel like after three months and going through a quarter of your junior year at a university, you should be able to figure out what you want currently. Figure out what it's like to be single and casually date possibly, like she wanted. Experience college life, going out with friends, etc, like she wanted. And living independently and being able to show herself she can run her life without having to have someone. And doing all this to get her heart to either tell her that she's ready and mature enough to make that commitment to taking things to the next step with us, or isn't mature enough and just wants to have college for two years and then make adjustments.

My one big outlying question is do I tell her come December when we officially reassess things and talk about our relationship, that I need to know then or soon after what she wants?

I think that in December, the agreed-upon reassessment time you both chose, you definitely have the right to know what she wants. There is a chance that she may not know, though, and then what will you do?


And on another note, you seem like a wise young man, and I think you will know when and if the waiting gets to be excessive.

Seems to me that your job is to give her time, and space, to make a decision.

Fact-She is dating, and having a great time.

So should you.

I think that in December, the agreed-upon reassessment time you both chose, you definitely have the right to know what she wants. There is a chance that she may not know, though, and then what will you do?


And on another note, you seem like a wise young man, and I think you will know when and if the waiting gets to be excessive.



That's the thing. She may not know, and I feel like giving her until January at the latest, as we would be on winter break for a while would be ample time and even more ample time to think about it when we're back down here in town and not up there at school. I guess it's just something I need to play by ear. When we talk in December, I'll see how the conversation goes and if I see fit, I suppose bring up that knowing by Jan is my cutoff. If I feel it's really close, but I shouldn't pressure, I won't. But giving her much longer after January, I think is the point where I decide I've made enough sacrifice and she doesn't know by then, she isn't going to anytime soon.

Seems to me that your job is to give her time, and space, to make a decision.

Fact-She is dating, and having a great time.

So should you.

It is. We're hanging out this weekend because we're doing a biking thing next weekend that we're training for, but other than that, I most likely won't be calling her, but wait for her to contact me to hang out or something. Having fun is just hard for me so far up there. Just moved up there, I live 10 miles out of the city, my housemates aren't around too much, and stuff I like to do, I like to do it with friends and not so much a solo thing- like biking, hiking,etc. Just keeping myself occupied with friends, work I guess is the thing I can do.

My one big outlying question is do I tell her come December when we officially reassess things and talk about our relationship, that I need to know then or soon after what she wants? As said before, I don't want to pressure her, because I'm willing to sacrifice some things to make this work, but I can't sacrifice all my feelings and emotions, so it's gotta stop at some point.

What is the ultimate decision you want decided?

That she only wants to be in a relationship with you for the time being and see where 'dating' leads or that she wants to spend the rest of her life with you and marriage is the goal?

I will add that I don't think the end of a grading period is a good time to add distractions like what am going to tell my "boyfriend" to the stresses of finals.

We're hanging out this weekend because we're doing a biking thing next weekend that we're training for, but other than that, I most likely won't be calling her, but wait for her to contact me to hang out or something.

No way, does this hanging out on her terms, help YOU one bit. It explains your position better, and her influence on it. Just me mind you, but not a good idea. For one, it keeps you hoping, and for another it keeps you close, so you can't do other things or explore your own options and opportunities for fun and a great time.

As she must make any decisions without your influence, so must you see things without her influence.

If your going to see her this way, then see others as well.

What is the ultimate decision you want decided?

That she only wants to be in a relationship with you for the time being and see where 'dating' leads or that she wants to spend the rest of her life with you and marriage is the goal?

I will add that I don't think the end of a grading period is a good time to add distractions like what am going to tell my "boyfriend" to the stresses of finals.


I want her to decide if she wants to continue being independent and casually dating others and not be in a relationship or decide she's committed to this relationship, this is what she wants, and not necessarily say marriage, since that's a big big thing, but have her for sure wanting to be in this serious, committed relationship where our plan I guess is to spend a pretty long time together. So never mind, I guess yes, sort of a marriage goal thing. It's just getting her to decide whether she wants a relationship right now and is ready and mature enough to say yes, I want to be committed to you and continue with this relationship as it grows more serious and closer to possible engagement.

Fact- She ain't ready, nor wants what you want.

No way, does this hanging out on her terms, help YOU one bit. It explains your position better, and her influence on it. Just me mind you, but not a good idea. For one, it keeps you hoping, and for another it keeps you close, so you can't do other things or explore your own options and opportunities for fun and a great time.

As she must make any decisions without your influence, so must you see things without her influence.

If your going to see her this way, then see others as well.

It's a ride we decided to do a while back that I really want to do, and I guess I know how this all goes as I've been through it with her last year. After she has her space for a bit and is ready to hang out, then we'll hang out and from there if I feel like hanging out, I'll ask her. I won't hope, I know how it went last time and it worked all right and we eventually had a re-birth of our relationship and got back together. I want to stay close, just not too close that she can't figure things out on her own. I have no problem wanting to do other things and such, just I guess I'm not the type of person. As previously stated, I know what I want right now and I have no desire whatsoever to casually date someone or crap like that. Here's her time to have some space and figure out the future of our relationship. In the meantime, I'll stay busy with friends and work. I have no desire to date or see other girls in this period.

Fact- She ain't ready, nor wants what you want.

I wouldn't go as far as it's a fact, but a possibility, and that's why were taking this break for her to figure out what she wants right now. Me and a relationship, or single and a relationship down the road.

Did you guys ever get back together?


How are things going with you two? Any Updates you can share... going through a similar situation except she doesn't want to date others.

howareutoday134, if you need advice, please ask your question in a new thread. That way we can give you advice that is appropriate for your situation.

The op may or may not be back. So, waiting for him to respond may be futile.

Just curious what happened in his situation... im thinking about making one of my own

Threads merged

So, I'm in a bit of a dilema.
My girlfriend and I have a very long history. We've been together on and off for 4 years. After being together for a while, we broke up for 7 or 8 months. I found out she cheated on me the day before we broke up. We got back together again until September of last year. She left for school, I moved up there and then she told me she wanted to take a break. Then, in April, we got back together yet again and things have been great since until last week or so. She had been stressed with finals and such and was starting to get a tad more clingy. Coupled with that was the fact it was really hitting me for the first time that in August, I'm moving from Washington State to Minnesota for school and it won't be as easy as we thought. I'm starting to doubt that the relationship will hold up because of the one time she cheated. I trust her again, but still bothers me when I think of being a distance from each other. I also am now worried about myself being lonely without a relationship and having someone physically there to do stuff with, etc. I don't know what to do.

The one thing, though, is that I want to give this a shot at least for a month in to school. But with how I'm worrying about it, I feel like it's hard even to get to August.

So my question is, what do I do?

What's her feelings about it? I figure if a relationship can survive four years through what you have been through, then you can work this distance thing out too!!

She is very positive about it and wants it to work too. We had a simple romantic date last night and both of us felt a bit reconnected which helped. Just really hope things work. My plan for now is to try it for a month or so, see how things go. If I'm still doubting it or worrying she's lying because of past stuff, maybe I end it. But I don't want it to get to that.

Had another bad development. She keeps getting more insecure and also got very upset because I don't post statuses about her on Facebook? What the hell. I feel at a point where I can't deal with little things like this more than once more, esp. if these problems are as big and I'm not even moving yet.