PDA

View Full Version : The usual - She wants Space - but I think I may too


jhens05
May 12, 2009, 04:14 PM
I've searched on Google, as you can imagine, this last week has been the ''middle'' of the situation, so I've been searching for answers and some sort of reassurance.

I've been dating my girlfriend for 3 years. Just to give you a glimpse of how close we were, we've given promise rings, I work for her family, and unfortunately (I realize now), we spent time with each other every day.

Recently, within the last week and a half, she began getting off work and hanging out with her girlfriends more often. Something I'm cool with, but was slightly unusual for her to do as often as she has been. There's an underlying layer here, and that's that throughout our relationship, she has, and as have I, somewhat abandoned our close friendships.

Anyway, this group of friends consists of say 5 people, I was the 6th. As I would go and hang out with them at times, even during the beginning of our troubles a couple weeks ago. There are 2 girls, her cousin Brandon, and his best friend Alex. Alex is the 2nd underlying layer. He likes my girlfriend, and while her and I were fighting over the little issues, he was there to cheer her up. At this current stage, they have yet to develop anything more than a friendship. I have spoken with him about the situation, the night her and I fought, and he had let me know that she had said she doesn't want a relationship, and that she's not sure what she wants, but she does know that she's feeling smothered by me.

That's where it is with that guy. The thing that's been heart wrenching is that while I've been curious and jealous of him, that was a normal reaction to these types of situations throughout our relationship, including on her end. She didn't like me talking to my ex, or girls I went to Prom with, etc. So as you can imagine, I felt reacting in a jealous way was normal in the realms of our relationship. It was, but eventually, I began to beat a dead horse.. and began to nag, doubt, question, and most of all push her away. I know the feeling, as she has done it to me in the past about certain issues, where I just felt like - LEAVE ME ALONE, I'M OUT OF HERE! Who wants to deal with stress when the alternative is a good time?

I've struggled with not contacting her. I know it's the key to allowing the pressure to ease off. I struggled until this weekend, on Saturday I didn't call her the entire day or night. I fought it. The next day I did call, as she has not said '' don't call or contact '', but the main agitation comes with me bringing up issues and resulting in an argument. That's what she can't stand, and I'm fooling myself to think that it's good in my department as well.

Anyway, Sunday I called her at work. Her voice lacked that agitated distaste and was replaced by a little more interest in hearing my voice. This was definitely a nice change for me.

So Sunday night, I was at a friends, and she called his house and asked to come up, as I had told her I'd be there. She came up, which of course delighted me, to the point where I was watching the driveway, even wondering when she'd be there. When she arrived, I handled the situation the way I know is better, which is not getting on her about anything regarding the guy, or our relationship, at least not in a confrontational away. By avoiding that, we then hung out, talked, and honestly without tension, enjoyed the night.

Here are a few things she said/did to me during the time she had come up:

She had told me she loves me. She hugged me, looked to see if I was wearing my ring. I do know she still has an interest of whatever sort in me and my feelings. I just know that I'm not playing the situation to the best I can.

She also said one key thing, or two rather.. basically something like:

'' Half of me wants to embrace you so badly, the other half still wants to have fun ''

And something like

'' I want to be close with you, but I still have boundaries and don't want to give you the impression that we can kiss/touch etc. because it will send off mixed signals. ''


I have told her, and the thing isn't so much that I don't want her to have space or time with her friends, I told her she can have all that she wants. For me, it's the doubt seeping into my mind regarding this Alex guy. I usually trust these parts of my judgement. I truly did have a suspicion he was interested in her, and he took advantage of the fight her and I had and only then let her know that he liked her. I thought that was ty of him, but very opportunistic.

As of right now, I know that not calling her or talking, or driving by her house is the absolute thing to do. I know I want to go out with my friends, go to the gym, and do other things.

The final thing is this, as soon as this situation happened, it was like a spark went off where all I could think about was being with her. Before this, there were many times where I'd felt suffocated myself by her jealousy, and had urges to branch off, but I'd always loved her and was satisfied for the most part by staying in the routine we had. What I'm basically saying is, absent makes the heart grow fonder as they say, because before this situation, I was arguing with her, and there were so many times where I felt I was neglecting friends/wanted time alone.. but the whole time I loved her, so I never really stayed away.

I'm not sure what's to come of the situation. Obviously, I love the girl as a person, not just as a girlfriend who gives me attention. I do very badly want to be with her, but I realize if anything after this, even if things go back to the way they were, I need to change and so does she, and we both need to allow more time for each other. I have told her very simply - Sarah, if you want to be with Alex, out of respect for the relationship, I want to know. I just don't want to be waiting and sitting her. She has repeatedly said that she realized she doesn't like him, but he is nice to her. I can only hope it's true, but I still obviously have my doubts. I can't allow my doubts or hopes to really dictate my emotions though, and I know only time will tell if something does come up with the two of them. I imagine he feels in a strange spot as well. But he should.


Basically, I'm just looking for opinions about this. It's Tuesday now, so yesterday I did see her, but today I'm trying to make sure I don't talk to her.. and when or if she calls me, I have to make sure not to nag her about what she's been doing.

jhens05
May 12, 2009, 04:16 PM
I have spoken with him about the situation, the night her and I fought, and he had let me know that she had said she doesn't want a relationship, and that she's not sure what she wants, but she does know that she's feeling smothered by me.


This part, he didn't say that she didn't want a relationship with me, but that she doesn't want one with him.

ajGambino
May 12, 2009, 04:40 PM
It seems your thoughts and indications towards Alex might be true. I'm sorry for all that's happened man, but you shouldn't even be talking to her at all. Keeping in contact with her will just confuse you and make you struggle to heal properly.

I think she's seeing this Alex guy and is lying to you, to spare your feelings. It's sad, it's terrible, but you have to be strong and move on with your life. I think she's not telling you the whole story. She wouldn't even mention this guy if she wasn't interested in him, much less let him comfort her when she's having a problem with you.

I would steer away from them, rebuild your life without her and avoid contact with her. As hard as that seems right now, it's the right steps you need to take, to get yourself back on track.

jhens05
May 12, 2009, 05:05 PM
Thanks.

I'm slowly, but needfully coming aware of the actions I need to make to get over this situation.

As for the situation with Alex. I wouldn't be surprised for her to think not telling me the truth and preventing that heartbreak would be the right choice, but if that is the case, she has to realize the result will be the same, and for the sake of what we've experienced as friends, hopefully she can be honest with me if anything between the two develops.

ajGambino
May 12, 2009, 05:43 PM
For the sake of your sanity and well being, you should not be friends with her right now. She broke up with you and that's going to sting for a while.

You need to be able to breathe without her first, create some room from her and surround yourself with the things that make you happy. If you want to be friends with her, you need to heal from all of this.

IWHO
May 12, 2009, 05:58 PM
Usually I don't agree with Gambino, sorry... fellow Texan.. lol... but this time I think he is right... I think both of you need to back away from each other for a while and see what you REALLY want... you smothered each other and both of you didn't like that... you pull away, then you want each other... you both need time to think about what it is that you really want...

ajGambino
May 12, 2009, 06:09 PM
Usually I don't agree with Gambino, sorry...fellow Texan..lol...but this time I think he is right....I think both of you need to back away from each other for a while and see what you REALLY want....you smothered each other and both of you didn't like that....you pull away, then you want each other.....you both need time to think about what it is that you really want.....


I hate you... fellow Texan. Lol

jhens05
May 12, 2009, 06:28 PM
Usually I don't agree with Gambino, sorry...fellow Texan..lol...but this time I think he is right....I think both of you need to back away from each other for a while and see what you REALLY want....you smothered each other and both of you didn't like that....you pull away, then you want each other.....you both need time to think about what it is that you really want.....


I agree. I honestly don't see this situation like she found a guy.. and began distancing herself from me. There had been times where we'd spoken of taking time away in the past, because the smothering, jealousy and agitation would make us argue.

I don't doubt she may have an interest in Alex. But she has made it very clear - she wants her and I to return to normal. For me, the problem isn't so much the situation, but just as you guys say, taking advantage of the break for myself too.


But like I said, right now it's tough more than ever, not because of the guy, just because the sudden change in routine. She doesn't want me to see other people, she's said that, and she said she isn't developing a relationship with Alex - but didn't deny that he was nice to her, and that right during the break up, probably liked the attention he gave her.

The very key thing for me honestly is just not breaking the no contact rule, and to control my thoughts whenever I do speak to her. I don't want to push her into the situation even more.

In the mean time, I'll be at the gym, working, and trying to catch up with a couple old friends as well. I plan on taking the next several days and making sure not to call her, we'll see what transpires in that time, but I know that won't be the fix, but it's a start to see where she'll be at after a few days of not seeing or hearing from me. Which is rare for the two of us.

IWHO
May 12, 2009, 06:29 PM
Wow <sniff sniff>... that was kind of harsh wasn't it?. wait a minute... that's why I don't usually agree with you... 'cause I think you are kind of HARSH... lol... be nice Gambino... I have extra ice cream I will share with you... :-)

jhens05
May 12, 2009, 06:33 PM
For the sake of your sanity and well being, you should not be friends with her right now. She broke up with you and that's going to sting for a while.

You need to be able to breathe without her first, create some room from her and surround yourself with the things that make you happy. If you want to be friends with her, you need to heal from all of this.


Thanks. I know this is the right advice. I don't plan on seeing other people though, or trying to develop a relationship with anyone else, or be physically close with another girl either. I don't want to do that, because obviously, I'm still in love with this girl. But I had noticed, the one day I didn't speak to her at all, even one day, did do wonders for the conversation and the way we interacted the next day. She reached out to me after that and tried to come see me, without me saying a word. That to me was at least a good sign. I didn't ask her if she loved me, she came to me and told me she did. She's been the advocate for this time being good for ''us''. She said she wants me to do whatever I want when we aren't together, and I asked her how she would feel when we weren't together, and she was out doing other things, and she said she felt that it was good because we were away from the stress, and that way when we did speak, the situation had kind of depressurized itself.

The guy in it is one thing, but the root of the problem was before that for sure.

IWHO
May 12, 2009, 06:33 PM
You can always come back online here and help others with their difficulties too... that's how I ended up here... I had a "situation"... and staying here and helping others has helped me stay on track with my own situation...

IWHO
May 12, 2009, 06:36 PM
but the root of the problem was before that for sure.

That's good that you can see that so clearly... good luck... hope things work out in the best possible way for you...