PDA

View Full Version : Mystery of sound


binatadasgupta
Mar 20, 2009, 03:18 AM
Some years before,when I was in my in-laws house,which is a 3 storied old building-i heard a loud prolonged sound of some heavy object as if pushing by someone,on upstaires.I was in 2nd floor and my in-laws are sleeping on 3rd.the sound was coming from 3 rd floor!! And it was 2.30-3.00 a.m of morning!! My sleep was broken by that loud sound!but my husband was in deep sleep!I left the room and start loking here and there.
Not a single sign of light was there! I mean,there was no sign that such a huge sound can be made!. explain me please.

sarnian
Mar 20, 2009, 04:13 AM
Hello binatadasgupta

Well, what would you expect to have happened when you heard between 2.30-3.00 am a loud noice on the floor above, where your in-laws sleep, and where all was dark ?

I ask myself WHY you went upstairs. Are you so curious? And WHY do you still bother about what may have happened there and than ? Just let it go!!

binatadasgupta
Mar 20, 2009, 04:27 AM
Thanks sarnian for your response.
I have your ans.
1.not a single thing happens in this earth without reason,logic.such a prolong loud sound on such an uneven time,is absolutely impossible.I am obviously frightened and curious also.but only to search a logic-though I was in fear,I went upstairs.
2.this thing bothers me,because still this is unexplainable to me.
I am a homo sepience,
Logic and explanation is my character.

sarnian
Mar 21, 2009, 02:56 AM
Hello binatadasgupta

Re. sound : sound can be made by certain events, or be experienced in our brains - even if there was no sound at all (like in a dream or nightmare). There is no way afterwards to be sure what did actually happen around 2.30 - 3.00 a.m. but I expect it was related to a dream/nightmare.
Your family did not hear anything, nobody broke his or her bed, nor did anyone find the house in chaos the next day. This should tell you that my expectation of dream/nightmare is most probably correct.

Re. Home sapiens : I also am a curious type of person. My entire life is based on logic, explanation, evidence, and on skeptism towards unsupported assumptions and acceptance. But around 2.30 - 3.00 a.m. I am in bed and will not 'inspect' another part of a house that is not mine, just because I think I heard a noise. If there was such a long "loud prolonged sound of some heavy object as if pushing by someone, upstairs" (the floor above where the inlaws resided) than I would stay in bed unless I would also hear later sounds indicating people moving around there, apparently in need of repair or reset of something that actually happened. As that did not happen indicates strongly that it happened in your dream/nightmare only.

Your insistence that this unnoticed (other then by you), unsupported, and probably never having occurred sound is real, and therefore is some unexplained paranormal phenomena, is to say the least rather strange, as you claim to be someone with logic and explanation in his/her character.
With all respect : why can't you accept the obvious : that this happened in your dream/nightmare? Why does a person with logic in his/her character even consider a paranormal phenomena as cause of your (and yours only) experience?

binatadasgupta
Mar 21, 2009, 03:26 AM
Good afternoon sarnian,
1.that night surely my sleep was broken by that loud sound,but it was a prolonged sound.
After I get up,and came to 100% consciousness,
The sound continues.at least for one and half mnt long.and that is no dream-no nightmare.
2.I was talking about my in-laws house.my own mother-in-laws house.in india after a girls marriage,this is certain that we should stay at that house.do you get me?I mean,every corner of that house,was and is my concern surely-and that type of access is authorised to me by my in-laws.this is normal here,very common.
3.the history of me,tell you I am a sound sleeper.I rarely saw dreams.good or bad never matters.-another thing,I born and brought up in a military family.myself completed some cadet corp training.so when my sleep is over-i get up like a bow.100% ready for any work.no amount of drousiness is there.
4.I can accept your theory of dream sarnian. But I was conciouss that night-as I am conciouss now.

sarnian
Mar 21, 2009, 07:44 AM
Hello again binatadasgupta

I know many of the common traditions and living arrangements in India. I do not doubt that you are authorised to search the house, but to do so between 2.30-3.00 am sounds rather nosey to me!

You say that you heard that sound, got up, and came to 100% consciousness. So you confirm that you were not fully conscious when you heard that sound. Note that every human being dreams frequently. Many of us are not (often) aware of that, but we all do dream. And I guess that night was one of these nights that you dreamt to hear that noise, and woke up from that.

You previously stated that logic and explanation are in your character. Why than do you seem to insist that this 'noise' occurred, while nobody else heard it, and the next day nothing appeared to be wrong or destroyed?
Why do you ask for a paranormal explanation when the rational explanation is so obvious?

Anyhow : did you ever speak with your family members about this, and if so : what was their opinion?

binatadasgupta
Mar 23, 2009, 02:27 AM
Hello sarnian,
I have no problem to admite that I was sleeping when that sound starts-but I wake up,
And came out from bed.I was standing and looking towards upstairs.and the loud heavy sound continues.and then I was 100% conciouss undoubtably.
In my in-laws house allmost all are aged people.so in 2.30-3.00 a.m at morning making such noise is absolutely impossible.
So I was more curious.
Next day no abnormality reported anywhere in the house.
I obviously told this thing to all.
They all saw me and told,many of there family heard this sound.some even saw some images.
I am asking for paranormal explanetion, because there was normal.