I've been searching for a certain movie for years, problem is I don't know the name of it! All I know is a brief plot. It was released around 2000, I rented it the same night I rented Virgin Suicides. It wasn't a very popular film, but I really want to see it again, as does my friend. The plot was that there was a family in a rather large house, the parents go away and one sister murders the other at the front door with theatrical mask, this sister keeps a suitcase under the house. This is just about all I can remember, if you remember a similar plot and think of anything else that could help, please reply, thank-you! :)

Why don't you go back to the store where you rented Virgin Suicides and see if they keep your rental history?

Loved that movie. Called wicked.