Log in

View Full Version : Do sanctions (aka virtue signaling) work?


tomder55
Jan 19, 2022, 07:32 AM
Clueless Joe thinks his threats of sanctions will deter Russia . History says not .

The US and EU slapped severe sanctions on Russia after they seized Crimea .The hit on Russia's GDP barely moved the needle;a 1.5% hit . It did not reduce popular support for Vladdy. It did not force Russia to return the peninsula to Ukraine. It did not help any internal opposition to Putty .It did not hurt his core oligarch compadres . It did not address the issues of self determination . It did nothing to signal NATO resolve because he knows NATO will never back up sanctions with the threat of meaningful miliary force.

What it did was advance a greater Russi-China economic cooperation . Russia is divesting itself of dollars in favor of Yuan
.Why are Russia and China ditching the U.S. dollar? - Russia Beyond (rbth.com) (https://www.rbth.com/business/332673-russia-china-us-dollar-america)


In reality what is happening is a greater Moscow -Beijing -Tehran axis while NATO has demonstrated again and again that it is a paper tiger .NATOs last military intervention in Afghanistan ended in an embarrassing disaster . NATO has demilitarized to the tune of more than half it's tanks since 2000 .

• Chart: Nato capability reductions & cost cutting. A step too far? | Statista (https://www.statista.com/chart/3058/armed-forces-reductions/)


The willingness of NATO to intervene short of symbolic sanctions is at best mixed. UK evidently wants to give defensive weapons ;but had to fly around Germany . Germany ;dominated by Greens pukes worries about offending Russia,their gas station.

So how effective are sanctions ? I would like to see the example when they meaningfully reversed a nations behavior . I can think of one when the world united to pressure South Africa to give up it's nukes .
There was a decade of sanctions against Saddam Hussein in Iraq . Those failed . Sanctions against Iran have failed to deter their nuclear program. Sanctions against the NORKs have not stopped the Kim regime from developing nukes and intercontinental ballistic missiles . Decades of sanctions did not dislodge the Castros in Cuba . Sanctions against Serbia did not compel them to abandon Kosovo (military intervention did ) Sanctions did not prevent Myanmar military takeovers .
Further the unintended consequences of sanctions is that they most often hurt the people in the country you are trying to protect.

Sanctions will not work and military response by NATO is a non-starter .

So where to go from here ?
Russia's stated goal is the protection of Russian populations in border states. They also want a buffer against NATO expansion up to their border . There is a significant ethnic Russian populations in Donetsk and Luhansk regions .
One possible solution is to grant autonomous zones for these regions .
Another possible solution is what happened during the Cold war when the 1955 Austria State treaty secured Austrian independence with the provision that it did not join NATO. Austria became a stable and free buffer state between WARSAW PACT and NATO nations

Athos
Jan 19, 2022, 12:44 PM
So where to go from here ?
Russia's stated goal is the protection of Russian populations in border states. They also want a buffer against NATO expansion up to their border . There is a significant ethnic Russian populations in Donetsk and Luhansk regions .
One possible solution is to grant autonomous zones for these regions .
Another possible solution is what happened during the Cold war when the 1955 Austria State treaty secured Austrian independence with the provision that it did not join NATO. Austria became a stable and free buffer state between WARSAW PACT and NATO nations

Russia did not threaten to invade Austria in 1955.

I hope there are more solutions than you suggested. It reads very much like Neville Chamberlain in 1938.

tomder55
Jan 19, 2022, 04:33 PM
no all the Russians did was occupy Austria for a decade until the 1955 treaty .

Show me the leader in NATO who has the balls . How many Americans are you willing to sacrifice for a European nation none other are willing to defend except perhaps Poland ? How many of them are clamoring for Ukraine to join NATO ? answer ZERO . Why don't they want it ? Because they would then be obliged to defend it .

Clueless Joe talks tough and carries a wet noodle. So do all the aniti -Putin putzes in Congress .Their tough talk is all demagoguery .

Wait until the weather gets cold and Putin stops the spigot of Russian gas exports to all those Green Euroweenies .

Zelensky pressed Clueless on membership during his visit to the White House in September. “I would like to discuss with President Biden here his vision, his government’s vision of Ukraine’s chances to join NATO and the time frame for this accession, if it is possible,”
President Biden Meets with Ukrainian President Zelensky | C-SPAN.org (https://www.c-span.org/video/?514402-1/president-biden-meets-ukrainian-president-zelensky)

It would be folly to allow it !

tomder55
Jan 19, 2022, 04:55 PM
Speaking of Chamberlain like ...... Clueless had a presseer today indicating that Putin's success is inevitable and that a "minor incursion ' by Russia would receive a lesser penalty.

Athos
Jan 19, 2022, 06:06 PM
no all the Russians did was occupy Austria for a decade until the 1955 treaty

Irrelevant. Russia has not occupied Ukraine for a decade. What they did was invade Ukranian territory and are threatening to do it again.


Show me the leader in NATO who has the balls . How many Americans are you willing to sacrifice for a European nation non......................................to defend except perhaps Poland ? How many of them are clamori.............ng for Ukraine to join NAT would then be obliged to defend it ........................................ Joe talks tough and carries a wet noodle. So do all the aniti -Putin putzes in Congress .Their tough talk is all demagoguery

What you are suggesting is do nothing short of war. Are you ready to go to war? You have no idea what the planned sanctions are. Maybe it would be best to stop the appeasement talk which only encourages Putin.


Zelensky pressed Clueless on membership during his visit to the White House in September. “I would like to discuss with President Biden here his vision, his government’s vision of Ukraine’s chances to join NATO and the time frame for this accession, if it is possible,” Wouldn't you want the same thing if you were Ukraine with a war-monger on your border?


It would be folly to allow it !

Folly for who?

tomder55
Jan 20, 2022, 03:31 AM
So who is the appeaser ?..... me or Clueless Joe ? I suggest diplomatic solutions that are well short of invasion . Joe made a statement that said a minor incursion is acceptable . Stinkin Blinken is on a mission that will end up with talks with Lavrov tomorrow . Is Joe's proposal on the docket , or did Joe blunder with his mouth as he oft does?

MSN (https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/did-biden-and-putin-cut-a-deal-here-s-why-ukrainian-officials-are-suspicious-that-happened/vi-AASWOwT?ocid=msedgntp)

Hunter Biden's pay masters were horrified


Folly for who? It would be folly to allow Ukraine admittance into NATO . NATO is ONLY a US guarantee of European security so they can go about their economic interests.

The real issue is Russia's security depends on a buffer states zone ;as has been true since the 17th century. NATO has already chipped at that buffer since the Soviet breakup. Make no mistake. It is existential to Russian security.

We were ready to exchange nukes over Cuba . This is no different . Kennedy negotiated a deal with Khrushchev where they removed the nuclear threat from Cuba in exchange for us removing the nuclear threat from Turkey. That is how diplomacy works . Nothing appeasing about it .

Athos
Jan 20, 2022, 11:27 AM
It would be folly to allow Ukraine admittance into NATO . NATO is ONLY a US guarantee of European security so they can go about their economic interests.

The real issue is Russia's security depends on a buffer states zone

What do you do if Russia invades Ukraine?

jlisenbe
Jan 20, 2022, 11:51 AM
What do you do if Russia invades Ukraine?Great question. Perhaps we should also be asking what we should be doing NOW before an invasion happens.

tomder55
Jan 20, 2022, 12:24 PM
What did GW Bush do when Russia invaded Georgia ? Nothing .

What was the international response to Russia invading Georgia ? What was the EU response ? EU leaders led calls for a ceasefire that favored Russian interests. French President Nicolas Sarkozy negotiated ceasefire terms that Moscow largely violated without consequence.The US under the new emperor regime called for a reset in relations with the Kremlin.

What was the reaction to Russia annexing Crimea .Mostly the world yawned until the Russians downed the MH17 passenger airliner. Then the sanctions began.

I don't know if Russia will invade. My own opinion is that Putin needs a face saving way out like Khrushchev was given.

tomder55
Jan 20, 2022, 02:21 PM
So Putin and Madura in Venezuela are in active talks .

Maduro, Putin talk after diplomat hints at military activity | WVNS (wvnstv.com) (https://www.wvnstv.com/news/world/maduro-putin-talk-after-diplomat-hints-at-military-activity/)
Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov led the Russian delegation at the talks with the U.S. in Geneva, on Jan. 13 . He spoke of the possibility of deploying military assets to his country’s two allies in the Western Hemisphere. That would be Venezuela and Cuba .

Look at a map of US ports on the Gulf of Mexico coast .
https://www.ajot.com/images/uploads/article/Gulf-Ports-Combined.jpg

Now look at the larger Gulf Coast .region and note the choke point established by the two nations All shipping commerce coming in or out of the Gulf including through the Panama canal must pass through this choke point.https://omniatlas-1598b.kxcdn.com/media/img/articles/main/northamerica19590101large.png

Russian and /or Chinese military assets here and you may appreciate what Russia thinks of NATO troops a couple hundred miles from Moscow Maybe we could or maybe we could not defend US commerce through this choke point
https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/image/jpeg;base64,/9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQAAAQABAAD/2wCEAAoHCBUVFRgVFhYZGRgZGRoaGBwZHBoYIxwYGhkZGhkYGR gdIy4lHh4rHxkYJjgmKy8xNTU1GiQ7QDs0Py40NTEBDAwMEA8P GBERGjQhGSExNDQ0PzExNTQ/NDQ0MTQ0NDQ1PzExNDQ0PzE0NDE0ND8xMTQ0NDExMTQ0NDExND Q0Mf/AABEIALsBDgMBIgACEQEDEQH/xAAbAAEAAwEBAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAwQFAgEGB//EAD8QAAIBAgMDCAcHBAICAwAAAAECAAMREiExBEGRBRQiMlFTY XETUnKBocLSBhUzkrLR8EKxweEjs0PxJGKi/8QAFwEBAQEBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAECA//EAB8RAQEBAQACAgMBAAAAAAAAAAABEQISIQNBIlFhE//aAAwDAQACEQMRAD8A/TNr2pxUYByoBAAAT1VO9SdTOae1NbpVH9wp/RONs/Ff2l/QkhlFl9qa1xUfXQinp29WcNtFSwIqt5YUy/8AzIYhUvOqveNwp/RHOqveNwp/RIogS86q943Cn9Ec6q943Cn9EiiBLzqr3jcKf0SfZ67NkarA VP6JTndAXZfMQjSwv3j8Kf0yvtL1FsRUe3iKf0S3I6qAqQZBQ5 1V7xuFP6I51V7xuFP6JFEqpedVe8bhT iOdVe8bhT iUtu2xKKF3NlBUXsTmzBVAA3lmA98ho8rUXbCHAfCrFXujAPiw 3VrG/QbLw8YGnzqr3jcKf0Rzqr3jcKf0TNblagHWn6RMTLiADA5XQAk 7rmolr64sp5tnKtKmFLMTjZkQIC5Z0DFlAUG5GBsvC2sDT51V7 xuFP6I51V7xuFP6JlvyvQDmm1RVcBmIY4eioQkknTrrr49kspt aM2BXQthxYQwJwm1msDe2Yz8RCLfOqveNwp/RHOqveNwp/RKG37elEKXJGNsCgKWLMVZsIA1NlY 6Rfe9G7rjAZAGdT0WwlFe4U2JFnXyJtrCtTnVXvG4U/ojnVXvG4U/olSjtSOWVHRipswVgSpuRZgDlmDr2GVdm5Z2d0FUVFCMxUFzgu R2YraixHaCDoYGrzqr3jcKf0Rzqr3jcKf0TN2jlWgnWqILOEbp DoMQxAfPoZKdbSVtupAsDUQFVDNd16Km1mOeQzGfjCLvOqveNw p/RHOqveNwp/RKP3hRsT6VLLhxHGthiNlub5XOk6obVTc2R0Y4Q1lZWOFs1awO huLHxhVznVXvG4U/ojnVXvG4U/olBOUKRprVLqqOAVZyEHS061s/CdPt9JcQNRAUtju6jDi6uLPK/jAu86q943Cn9Ec6q943Cn9EzF5XoF3QVFvTvjzsFsiOSScrYXX PTUbjJRyhRuB6VLsuJRjXNbE4hnmLK2fgYF7nVXvG4U/ol3kuuzFwzE2wkXCjXFcZAdkyaNZXUMjKynQqQwO7IiaXI3Wfy T54RX2z8V/aX9CSGTbZ K/tL hJDCkREoREQEREBOkaxvOYga6jKeypsda ROgy90tzKMvaKeFiOHlI5b2/UeUqqBvylVX23ZRURkJKg2zGE6G9iGBUjLMEEETJX7MUlUKr1F wqgFsGWA1CCAUsMqrrYCwBFgLCb5tu MMvA6QPnav2ZTC B2DGm9NA EqpqLTUv0VDYv JGHSsCMrS3tXIaPQTZyzBEAGiNi6NiWDqwJPWva4OYM1YgYe0/Zmk7Fi7i5ByKnMegwm5Um4Ozoc9c73vJ9h5Cp0qgqIzghBTw9F VICqoYqqi5sg8BnYCasSjO2vkam9M0s1QsWIGFwSb3DLUDKwz0 IyIBFrSu32bpFSuJ7EYesCbehSj1iCT0UBz33mzEgxti5BCLVv UfFU9KuJcK4EqVKlTodHrAvq18x2ZSKp9laBVkBdVZWBGLFYvQ bZyylwSDgKjW3QXLW 9EoyafISLljcr6Q1FU4LKzGozAHDiILVXOZNsrWkSfZmkBhxuV w4QCUyNqas18NySKaXBNtbATbiEYW1fZ8FnqJUf0jMrAuQwXA9 RwF6On/K4sb5W7AR1yD9nU2bCysWcU0QkhbXVKSM65YlxCimWIjKbcSKx E zqhFQ16rKh6F/RdAFXRlWyZgq5HSudLETpvs8mB0D1FRjfCCnRuSWAJXEQxY3DE FpsxAw2 zNIknG eG2adFlWgocdHX/41I2NxcHKxtA zFHO5c4usTgOI32gsSMNsztNQkaaWAAsdyIFTkzYVoUxTVmYAs bubnpEm2QAAzyAGU2eRus/knzyjL3I3WfyT54qK 2fiv7S/oSV2cCWNs/Ff2l/QkrsT2XhTGP8T0GcYv8A6ySUIiICIiAiIgdI5U3E0qFTEL8Zlz tXI0Mgk2x7t5ZSCek3nkBPTnwlipRsgOXj75XMDyJ7PJQiIgIi ICIiAiIgIiICIiAiIgJe5G6z SfNKMvcjdZ/JPmkor7Z K/tL hJDJts/Ff2l/QkhgIiDKEREBERATmoThOHNrG1 22XxkiUy2gne07EcDdMg2NsNgb2yALZXv25SW5Et9MYbVtPS/4ENicJFQDFm1st1gFBv26bpIm0VzkaIU4Lgh1YB79W1x/TnfS WWsm z3Jj01Za1TExa64WBXpdJrCwOLGW1y0tvmwdiXtPwmebbJbMrP HVslsyvn6u07SCcNAMAMruq3OWeptluz8 3Slh9kYC srzTbum4Fw2Ytl4GcREo9A3xfPOeT2B5E9ZbTyAiIgIiICIiAi IgIiICIiAl7kbrP5J80oy9yN1n8k aSivtn4r 0v6EmbtHJqO M4g HDdWtYWYWA0/rJ8wOyaW2fiv7S/oSQwMhuREs2KrWzN7hyuEAHK /XMnX4SXa RqdVSrs7KXNQAsDZijo2E2yUq5Fv8k3ucp8ktXosqsVZsgQWFg TZiQOsMN jv8NZa5E5L9FSVHJdxcFizNexIUgN1ejbLdnrqc V3M9Onhx/l5eX5bmZ9MpeR0DY8dW9zq5IzNzkR/Mt4BFzZ6QRQoLG29jcnO Zm5aQbSihDkB 81rkz56BPIlVbG1BVAUX88pGcT3OWW79pBOlcjQkSI9p1Su4Hz EsDbe1fjKkQrTpbQrDWx7JC7pl0NbHLxNuMpTpWIIPZGIsvRxD EL79Rn7 3zlVlINjNNKgYXBh6StqOEDLiW6uyWuQT4C15VZSNRChMXnqAX zNhD23fGUAlxecxEBERAREQEREBERAREQEvcjdZ/JPmlGXuRus/knzSUV9s/Ff2l/Qkhk22fiv7S/oSNn2ctnugXtnFlF ySREiEztpqksezQb E0D2TKc5mWDmIiVSIiAiJ6YHkREDpFubXt4mXadREFsV5QiQaI 2pO34TirtKEW1lGIxHTWvle268k5q9r2kMsUcdxZrA9uYJ4H/ABCoUpkmwE9akwFyDLxV7jpD br2nqq 9hoeO46fCNRmxLlfZXYai9ha2W/Pd/LynV2WotzlbO2 2ZsSbdluEBEiCv2j Xy08pLKpETL2hdqu5RqZBvgDAgr0jY4t4w2ytrfPcA1ImUtTaz/AEUhY7y2djbduOt9fDcZqNbaMah0TAb3KHq6akntJ0ByHEL8TO 2c7TcBxTK36Rzvh3kAWA8s7X1Ns69F9vC2ZKDNYZ4mAv0QcgNO sfeIGzL3I3WfyT55h7O 04wHWng3lS19Nym4GficpucjdZ/JPnkqJcALVLj sfoSdIgUZZQOtU9sf9dOek5yD24nhadSDE LQWz4XXx7MUCLamwnXOxFvA/7/tKcyX5P2kbWaj1G9GRhC4lJsBcXy6uIt46XMl2rkdHdnLOC4sw VsIIwYLEWzFu2Tnq2e5jr8vxzizOpdkvr6/jRiZ6ckoMsbkWAszAgYXFQHCRhvcAZjTKeJyQoxjG F1KlSbjMkkjdfMbt3ZNubRiZX3Gm56oyCiz6KtrBcstN00aFPA qrcnCALsbk23k7zAkiIgIiIHdJr5YB7zrr4 z8ZI9HTRb6Z3vxMgiRCxGRtffbMe6BESqstXU6oL8JyHT1D5Xy kESC/Q2gMbWseM5qbXZrAXA1lMGeRiLDbW18sh2az3nbWINpWiFcutw R2yTBRvhN72txsdZzED1kp5FL7 zfc/5 E8iLwIdrrYEZ8JbCLkLa9hmbYiB8ZS5C5T5xTx4GXMg3tYkdgB v2agTSdQQQQCDqDnfzEKoF7CxJufHK2fjYTNnW7vp1564nxXm8 71b6v6j2J7aeTbkS9yN1n8k aUZe5G6z SfNJRP/AFVPaH/XTnt/CRNixva3XH/Wn oIe2ovxGjf5w/GREqTx3C3J7Jwpe YW3gfH9rcJ2mKwxWvvtp5wM6q5dr28h4SOarELmSB4nKDUXtH8 8JdGYlMnQXnoptrY8JomqvaP/Wv9p0rA6GNGTE069ENrke2Z9VMJtCuIiJQiIgIiICLxOGQawOx EiCKdP8AMkVbQPYiICIiAiIgIiICIiB2qrhJJz0A/wAzidIRfMX1nMBL3I3WfyT5pRl7kbrP5J80lHNWvhqvfTEP0J 0srVU5giUNs/Ff2l/QkhhGveeZ6zLSoV0Mspth/qHCMFpgDkbH WnhpL2fzzkLbWtt9 yTq1xpY7x2SDxqSbwP/e7/UIgG62nwgVF3Ea2941j0q9o/ht/eB3hmdtbAube/wA5f9Iut/5/BMttZYPIiJVIiICIiAiIgLREQEREBERAREQEREBERATuqxJudb D3 M5EEwPJe5G6z SfPKQEu8jdZ/JPnkqK 2fiv7S/oSQybbPxX9pf0JIYUiQbVtSU1xOTYmwABdmPYiKCzG1zYAnKZ3 JXKNM9DG4ZnZU9IrJcqAMCltTZSwW IDUZSjYlrZtptk2nb2SrEg1GVFzIAz18TAopuVbbshKVOoSMB9 x7P9TrZqhU2N7HwPhmOI4iRFp6aAG6ggD/AHMwzQq1gVOHM2vodDloZnywIiJVIiICIiAiJ2tNiLgEwOIlld kJANx5HKT0dmCjPM/zQSaiCjshbM5DdIHWxI1tLe2YsiCbHK3jIU2Vj4ef7QI3pkAXG s8IGWfn4S82zXABYm3lIqmx qfcf3gVIiJVIiegQPInToRrOYHtsrzyJ7A8l7kbrP5J80oy9yN 1n8k aSivtn4r 0v6ElHbaroAUTH0gGG8LvI/m Xts/Ff2l/QkhgfJ8qbTV9JVdUKshSmHZ8Ho1ZVY4BgdWLsw6LdayA5rYUeT NpZmdSlR1dmcoi9EOUSmHx36CjASob ok3us r27k7GwdMIcFcQYXVwDljAsbrckH 8yuTORTgVDgVFD070yxcpe2DHlhQi WZzvkdAv8i7ZUdKYqKcRpI7ObdJzcHJchewbXRhNWcogUAAAAa AZADsAnUqO6AGIXyzltyQ1sC2NrG33dKM7FQ2tfK9/fINFF1JUA3sNMxulDaKWE G6T0drzsw94lmogIsdIGVEmq0CCbefukSKSbDOFeRLdPZN7afz UzrmyN1W4ZwKUSavsxXPUSGB0i3IHaRNVRbISns2zaMT42l2Kh PN89nIMgg2qsBYam4PAydWBFxK210L9IDPQ/vJ9nplVAMCSIiBX5mvjOhsqdnxMmiBSrbIb3XTsnFPZWJzyHjN CI0QLsq9l5ztFOwuqjxFh8JZiBnbOQGu1hbcR/i0jqtdifGabIDqJn7TTCmwlEMvcjdZ/JPmlGXuRus/knzRVV9s/Ff2l/QkhtNypsVJjdqak9pAJ4zn7uo90n5V/aNRiyOlRVAQotcknMnM6nOb33dR7pPyr 0fd1Huk/Kv7RoxbRabX3dR7pPyr 0fd1Huk/Kv7RoxbRabX3dR7pPyr 0fd1Huk/Kv7RoxlNiD2S0m1do33Gcv/AHdR7pPyr 0fd1Huk/Kv7QKI2klsjYZZEeOefwkio43rw1N/Ls/vLX3dR7pPyr 065hS7teAkGQ9ZyCrdv8AYfwcI1sxe82W5Oon/xp UTz7uo90n5V/aURJcjMa7pXSgA4yuDf3ES/wAwpd2vARzKn6i8BII7StTruRnTZTbS6nOxNr/zWXeZU/UXgI5lT9ReAgZ67TUuAaJAvYnEDYdtgM5620Pcj0TZXsQVIOZF tQfh7zL/ADKn6i8BPeY0vUXgIFEbQ f/ABMOiSLlLE7luDkT5WnK7U d6Li3ih4Z5y/zKn6i8BHMqfqLwECjzh7geiexOZuhtnrrB2hx/wCJusRkyk2Bsre/Xwl7mVP1F4Ce8xpeovAQM4bU R9C l7YkuD2Wvb4zzndTX0D29pL787X8taPMqfqLwEcyp ovAQKT7Q40pOdN6DW19TunnOH7p9bar25HXSXuZU/UXgI5lT9ReAgU2ruLWpuejfVRY rrr8Jy20Pcj0TG17HEtjmB23BIz098vcyp ovARzKn6i8BAonaHAv6Jr3OQKnIAWNyRre3uM4qsSQTSY9G qi1/6Tnr5TR5lT9ReAjmFLu14CBi1Kb6rTfyJXTwsfhLnI3We4tkmX Z1spe5lT9ReAnSUFTqqFvrYAXgf//Z

Athos
Jan 20, 2022, 02:21 PM
I don't know if Russia will invade. My own opinion is that Putin needs a face saving way out like Khrushchev was given.

Agreed.

I think Putin has a gigantic national inferiority complex. Guys like that usually back down. My 2 cents.

tomder55
Jan 20, 2022, 02:34 PM
I think Putin has a gigantic national inferiority complex.
I think the whole nation has an inferiority complex. But we did rub their face in it with our triumphalism after the collapse of the Soviet Empire .

Remember this nativity?

https://img.thriftbooks.com/api/images/m/9aeb415d2666261581df804728b1de56b9797ca1.jpg

Fukuyama, argued that the collapse of the Soviet Union represented the end of history in that universal Western democracy was to be the norm . That was before jidadistan ,tribalism ,and the reemergence of totalitarian dictators said 'hold on ;not so fast'

Athos
Jan 20, 2022, 03:23 PM
universal Western democracy was to be the norm . That was before jidadistan ,tribalism ,and the reemergence of totalitarian dictators said 'hold on ;not so fast'

And before the Republican Party decided to bail out and become the Trump Cult.

tomder55
Jan 20, 2022, 04:00 PM
you mean a nation considers its own self-interests instead of bowing to the dictates of unnamed unaccountable international bureaucrats?

Athos
Jan 20, 2022, 05:23 PM
you mean a nation considers its own self-interests instead of bowing to the dictates of unnamed unaccountable international bureaucrats?

No. I mean the Republican Party that has given up its once admirable principles and groveled at the feet of a madman who has nothing but his own sick self in mind.

jlisenbe
Jan 20, 2022, 07:17 PM
groveled at the feet of a madman who has nothing but his own sick self in mind.I think we just found out why it is that dems lying out the whazoo doesn't bother you but Trump's typical hyperbole does.

Wondergirl
Jan 20, 2022, 07:22 PM
Trump's typical hyperbole
Hyperbole???? (Ummmm, exaggerated statements or claims not meant to be taken literally)

jlisenbe
Jan 20, 2022, 08:32 PM
exaggerated statementsExactly correct.

You have not posted an opinion on the lies we have documented told by Biden and Clinton. Care to?

Wondergirl
Jan 20, 2022, 09:49 PM
You have not posted an opinion on the lies we have documented told by Biden and Clinton. Care to?
Why would I?

tomder55
Jan 21, 2022, 03:43 AM
This post isn't about Trump. If Trump were President, then he would've deployed Patriot batteries manned by US "advisors"; and the US Navy would be demonstrating in the Black Sea exercising "freedom of navigation". The US would've already shipped massive amounts of anti-tank armaments like MANPADS....and Putin already knows that Trump had no problem wasting a couple hundred Russian troops if they got in the way.

Trump's time had no effect on the failed predictions of Fukuyama. His thesis was knocked down by Samuel Huntington in "The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order”

It was internationalists like Bubba, GWBUSH, the emperor, Evita, and Clueless Joe who led us into 30 years of war. But they did not have the resolve to win it. Trump on the other hand tried to end foolish foreign engagements while at the same time building our military strength. The internationalist of the world love little interventions while at the same time they gut the military capabilities of their nations.

Clueless Joe in a rare moment of candor and mental acuity told us something that is self evident and something that Putin figured out a decade ago. The west will never risk blood and treasure defending Ukraine .The Europeans threaten "massive economic sanctions " if Russia does a full scale invasion. However ,the scale of the west response will be in proportion to the scale of Putin's aggression .

Joe told us that Wednesday ,Yesterday Ukraine and the hawks in the west squawked ;and the administration spent the rest of the day doing damage control spin.

He was telling a truth . A 'minor incursion' is acceptable to the Europeans . Any talk of massive retaliation would quickly be knee capped by the likes of Germany who depends on Russian gas because their windmills don't get the job done.

That will be considered a green light by Putin to carve out the territory he wants .

So if the west is not willing to fight for Ukraine then why even consider the addition of Ukraine into NATO? If NATO doesn't invoke rule 5 when a member state is attacked then any pretext of legitimacy of the pact is exposed as a fraud..... Or it is US to the rescue with cold war numbers of troop deployments backed up by the US Air Force .

We do not have the troop strength to make that commitment and to honor our ones in East Asia at the same time . The difference is that the defense of our allies in East Asia is of much greater strategic importance to us .The defense of Western Europe is only necessary because the eunuchs in the west don't have the testicular fortitude to defend themselves .

jlisenbe
Jan 21, 2022, 04:08 AM
Why would I?I didn't think you would since you scarcely ever speak harshly of a liberal dem. It's not lying that people here dislike. It's just an opportunity to bash Trump that must be joined. I'm not a fan of Trump, but I am a fan of consistency.

Let's let Tom have his thread back.

Wondergirl
Jan 21, 2022, 09:48 AM
I didn't think you would since you scarcely ever speak harshly of a liberal dem.
I'm a registered Republican. I speak harshly about anyone who is a poor leader.

jlisenbe
Jan 21, 2022, 09:55 AM
I don't think you do. Biden is certainly a poor leader, yet you won't dare even comment on his repeated lies. Clinton lied like a dog, and that is definitely poor leadership, yet you have nothing negative to say about that. As for being a registered repub, you are familiar with the old adage, "If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck."

And to be clear, I'm not being mean-spirited. I'm simply questioning your accuracy which is certainly appropriate. You are welcome to do likewise.

Wondergirl
Jan 21, 2022, 09:57 AM
Start your own thread about all this.

jlisenbe
Jan 21, 2022, 10:09 AM
About what?

We can move it here if you'd like. It's an old thread of mine that is basically dead.

https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/current-events/why-our-incarceration-rate-so-high-848928.html
(https://www.askmehelpdesk.com/current-events/why-our-incarceration-rate-so-high-848928.html)
I'm just not sure what we will be discussing. Post an answer there if you'd like to.

Wondergirl
Jan 21, 2022, 11:23 AM
I started a new thread about lying. Current Events.

tomder55
Jan 27, 2022, 02:33 AM
useful video of possible Russian strategy
Ukraine crisis: US weighs more military support for Ukraine to resist Russia if it invades - CNNPolitics (https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/18/politics/us-military-support-ukraine-russia/index.html)