I have been with this one guy for 8 months he is 20 years old. I really do love him and he gets along with my family so good. We have had a sexual relationship and I have known him for about a year and a half.

There is another guy now that started talking to me. I met him when I was in 8th grade, he was in high school. He makes me smile, laugh, and just feel happy and I always have liked him, we were once sexual (JUST sexual contact) no intercourse.

He does know I have a boyfriend and he doesn't know I like him the way I do now.
WHAT DO I DO!

I am 19.

Back away from both guys and figure out what you want first before taking the next step. Don't lead both guys on. Make a decision and stick with it.

Backing away from the situation allows you to think more objectively, because you won't have the influence of both guys that would make you swing back and forth.