| A few more thoughts. Explore filing a Criminal Fraud complaint. I understand that the police told you to file a Civil Complaint. I am not sure of local procedure there. You might inquire at the Office of the District Attorney/Prosecutor (usually a county office). Ask about filing a Private Criminal Complaint (the label used in PA, maybe called something different in your state). If they accept it, then they will prosecute the criminal charges (hopefully get the guy's attention), and you will need to cooperate, have documentation available (canceled checks, contract, pictures, etc), and the judge hopefully will be convinced and award restitution (where the county/state will collect the money and pass it on to you). If you cannot proceed with a Private Criminal Complaint, then you will have to file a Civil Complaint. You might look for a legal clinic, or an advertisement for a local lawyer where you get reduced legal fees, to explore the possibility of other relief. For example, PA has a Consumer Fraud Statute, where if fraud is proven, the victim can get awarded treble damages (you would get your $4k, plus more, up to $12k total). Again, I do not know local law there, and you should talk to a lawyer before you file (it is easier to file properly first, not have to amend a complaint later). As far as finding the guy, after you file a Complaint, you have more access to resources than the Federal Freedom Of Information I advised earlier. Once you file, you have a Caption and Docket Number, meaning you can now issue a Subpoena on the Depart. of Motor Vehicles to get copies of the guy's Drivers' License and Vehicle Registration data. I think consumers do not realize how tedious and frustrating the process can be. A word of caution though, you might go through all of this, go to court, get a judgment, and if the guy is "judgment proof", you will get no money. Some small businessmen (many contractors) have no bank account or real estate, and the process to take possession of a vehicle is not easy. Be very careful in the future. Some consumers will only deal with contractors who are "bonded" and have a positive rating with the BBB (Better Business Bureau). Another idea is to check the local dockets to see if others have sued this guy before. There may be a long line of judgments against him. You might then conclude it is not worth it to proceed. For a $4k claim, you really should talk to a local lawyer - many will offer an initial consultation for no charge. Good luck. |