In my experience, Neutrogena products dried out my skin. I too have combination skin. When I used Neutrogena, my skin dried out so much, my T-Zone was 'bone dry'.
What I suggest is to switch to another cleanser, perhaps Dove's Sensitive bar, it's really good and is suitable for acne prone skin.
Also, to exfoliate, use a muslin cloth. When you've got the soap on your face, get the cloth and gently massage the skin with it in gentle circular motions.
And a good moisturiser for night time would be Extra Virgin olive oil or Jojoba oil. They will not cause any acne breakouts. If you find it does, then just stop. A good tip for applying the oil to the face is when you've washed your face, apply the oil to damp skin and massage it in. I've found that really helps the oil sink into the skin.
Let me know how it works out for you!
