Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help!
  Advanced
Register  |  Log in  
   Ask    
 Answer  
  Help  

Ask QuestionsprogressAnswer QuestionsprogressBuild ReputationprogressBecome an Expert
 
Free Answers in 3 Easy Steps

Register Now
3 Steps

At Ask Me Help Desk you can ask questions in any topic and have them answered for free by our experts. To ask questions or participate in answering them you must register for a free account. By registering you will be able to:
  • Get free answers from experts in any of our 300+ topics.
  • Accept money for answers that you provide.
  • Communicate privately with other members (PM).
  • See fewer ads.

Home > Forum Community > Member Discussions > Religious Discussions   »   Was Monotheism the origin of religion?

 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Question
 
 
#1  
Old Feb 25, 2008, 10:05 AM
firmbeliever's Avatar
firmbeliever
Follower of Islam
firmbeliever is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: On a path to peace,complete peace!
Posts: 2,360
firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Was Monotheism the origin of religion?

http://www.bloomington.in.us/~lgthscac/monotheism.htm
http://cogweb.ucla.edu/Culture/Monotheism.html


I was just reading through these two links...

And would like your thoughts on them.

If possible links to other similar articles will be highly appreciated.

Thank you in advance..

Reply With Quote
 
     

Answers
 
 
Old Feb 25, 2008, 01:19 PM   #2  
Ultra Member
Dark_crow is offline
 
Dark_crow's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: La Playa
Posts: 1,406
Dark_crow See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Dark_crow See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Historian Dr. Albert Hyma wrote, I believe, in Streams of Civilization I: “According to many present authorities, the Sumerians were originally monotheistic in their belief, for the most ancient written records state clearly that they believed in only one God. This is a very important fact to note, because until very recently (1937) a large number of historians believed that mankind originally was polytheistic and that gradually as human beings became civilized, they formed a higher conception of the deity.”
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 25, 2008, 03:26 PM   #3  
Junior Member
Mr_am is offline
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 105
Mr_am See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
It started with Adam. Was Adam (the father of humanity) monotheist ? YES .. So his religion is the first religion.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 26, 2008, 02:06 AM   #4  
Science Expert
Capuchin is offline
 
Capuchin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 4,729
Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Call Capuchin via Skype™ Send a message via MSN to Capuchin
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr_am
It started with Adam. Was Adam (the father of humanity) monotheist ? YES .. So his religion is the first religion.
lol
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 26, 2008, 02:53 AM   #5  
Follower of Islam
firmbeliever is offline
 
firmbeliever's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: On a path to peace,complete peace!
Posts: 2,360
firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dark_crow
Historian Dr. Albert Hyma wrote, I believe, in Streams of Civilization I: “According to many present authorities, the Sumerians were originally monotheistic in their belief, for the most ancient written records state clearly that they believed in only one God. This is a very important fact to note, because until very recently (1937) a large number of historians believed that mankind originally was polytheistic and that gradually as human beings became civilized, they formed a higher conception of the deity.”
I have always believed in monotheism being the original religion since the beginning of human life in this world.
It is good to find archeological findings which support it,though my belief does not change even if there were no archeological evidence of it. I did always believe that the more research is done into the origin of religions,the more people will realise that all religions lead to one source.We are from the same source and unto the same source we will return.

I also believe that the universal laws that people find similar to the 10 commandments came from this very source.Which is why although one may not be a believer,they have certain values in them to discern right from wrong.
Of course there are those who uses their free will to do wrong even when they know it is not right.

"Finally, Dr. Wilhelm Schmidt, an Austrian, set out in the 1920's to compile every "alias of the Almighty" discovered by explorers around the world. It took Schmidt an amazing six volumes totalling 4,500 pages to detail them all! A minimum of a thousand more examples have come to light since then. An approximate 90 percent or more of the folk religions on this planet contain clear acknowledgment of the existence of one Supreme God! Schmidt's classic "Der Ursprung der Gottesidee" (The Origin of the Concept of God) was finally published in 1934."
http://www.freerepublic.com/forum/a393151a5332f.htm
Also from the above link.
"They had thoroughly debunked all pretensions about the supernatural origin of religion. Religion, they claimed, evolved mentally just as biological forms evolved physically.

Back on the Kalahari Desert, in the Ituri forest, and innumberable other locations, however; the young anthropologists were getting down to a deeper level of questioning. They would ask the animists: "By the way, who made the world?" and were startled to hear them respond, often with a happy smile, by naming a single Being who lived in the sky.

"Is he good or bad?" was a usual second question. "Good, of course", was the invariable reply. "Show me the idol you use to represent him", the researcher might ask. "What idol? Don't you know that he must never be represented by an idol?"

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr_am
It started with Adam. Was Adam (the father of humanity) monotheist ? YES .. So his religion is the first religion.
I agree with you on this.

From the appearance of the first human on earth and all the descendants from then were aware of the existence of an Almighty God,but then humans being humans have found their own interpretations of the guidace given to them and branched off into different beliefs in nature and the universe.

Hinduism, considered one of the oldest religions,it is mentioned in their books that there is non comparable to the One (Brahma).They have One God,but the priests of the same religion,thought that it will be hard for the commoners to understand and communicate with the One,they started worshipping nature and people as manifestations of the One,or worship through these objects to get to the One God.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 27, 2008, 02:39 PM   #6  
Full Member
michealb is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 461
michealb See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.michealb See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
My take which I'm sure most of you won't want to hear but I give it anyways.

The first article is based on work by Dr. Clifford Wilson who has an impressive list of degrees except for one small problem his degree in archaeology is an honorary degree which means he never studied archaeology.

Correct me if I'm wrong here but the second article seems to say that the temple was first used by polytheists then monotheists meaning the articles contradict each other.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 27, 2008, 03:52 PM   #7  
Junior Member
Mr_am is offline
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 105
Mr_am See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Quote:
Originally Posted by michealb
My take which I'm sure most of you won't want to hear but I give it anyways.

The first article is based on work by Dr. Clifford Wilson who has an impressive list of degrees except for one small problem his degree in archaeology is an honorary degree which means he never studied archaeology.

Correct me if I'm wrong here but the second article seems to say that the temple was first used by polytheists then monotheists meaning the articles contradict each other.
Could be true.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 27, 2008, 09:03 PM   #8  
Follower of Islam
firmbeliever is offline
 
firmbeliever's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: On a path to peace,complete peace!
Posts: 2,360
firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Quote:
Originally Posted by michealb
My take which I'm sure most of you won't want to hear but I give it anyways.

The first article is based on work by Dr. Clifford Wilson who has an impressive list of degrees except for one small problem his degree in archaeology is an honorary degree which means he never studied archaeology.

Correct me if I'm wrong here but the second article seems to say that the temple was first used by polytheists then monotheists meaning the articles contradict each other.
Thanks for correcting that,I dont really know Dr.Clifford Wilson.

Yes the second article does say that the temple was polytheistic before monotheistic,which is what was being said by most people that polytheism came before monotheism.
I do not agree with it.The temple may show polytheism came before monotheism,but the temple could have been built after the people became polytheists.

I think that polytheism was what people followed later,they changed their beliefs of monotheism over time and found their own versions of belief.
This is where the messengers had to be sent as reminders to help guide people to the right path.

I would also like to know why people believe that polytheism came first?

I have read an article which said that the "primitive" societies found their way to monotheism.Primitve I think might be only technologically(as compared to the present),but otherwise there must have been great thinkers,and builders even in those times.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 28, 2008, 01:20 AM   #9  
Science Expert
Capuchin is offline
 
Capuchin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 4,729
Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Capuchin See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Call Capuchin via Skype™ Send a message via MSN to Capuchin
Because archeological evidence shows that most civilizations BC believed in polytheism, mayans, aztecs, egyptians, greeks, romans, babylonians, assyrians, all polytheist.

I actually think that it's the other way around, many gods was too hard to understand so they dumbed it down into one almighty god who controlled everything.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Feb 28, 2008, 01:23 AM   #10  
Follower of Islam
firmbeliever is offline
 
firmbeliever's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: On a path to peace,complete peace!
Posts: 2,360
firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.firmbeliever See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Capuchin
Because archeological evidence shows that most civilizations BC believed in polytheism, mayans, aztecs, egyptians, greeks, romans, babylonians, assyrians, all polytheist.

I actually think that it's the other way around, many gods was too hard to understand so they dumbed it down into one almighty god who controlled everything.
"BC" as in Before Christ?
  Reply With Quote
 
     


Thread Tools
Display Modes

 
Similar Sponsors

Similar Threads
Question Asker Forum Answers Last Post
the origin aniyaomar Buddhism 1 Oct 28, 2007 03:14 PM
What is the Origin of this quote? granmaboat Philosophy 2 Aug 28, 2007 05:27 PM
Country of origin rabieskittie Christianity 11 Jul 11, 2007 06:49 AM
last name origin eve1988 Other Family & People 1 Apr 30, 2007 03:21 AM




Copyright ©2003 - 2007, Ask Me Help Desk.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:16 AM.