Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask

"I really like you, but I still love my ex of 10 yrs!"

Asked Aug 27, 2008, 05:06 PM — 666 Answers
This is how it goes down: my girl was with someone for 10 yrs! Since she was 15...they lived together for 3 yrs...they would break up and get back, but she would always go back to him...about 6 months ago, he asked her to marry him..she rejected his because she was moving to another country for work, and because she was willing to see what else is out there

Thats where I come in...about 4 months ago, I met her at a party and we hit it off....we really started falling for each other, and started to really like each other...she told me that I'm the only one for her, etc...she made it clear to me that she wants to move on with me and ditch her past, and concentrate on us, but she just needed time...for example, when we would be getting sexual, she would sometimes hesitate first, because it would be the first time with someone new (other than her ex of 10yrs)...I didn't care, I really liked her, so I respected her past, respected the fact that she was with someone for so long, and didn't mind taking it slow with her until she fully forgets about him

Things were going fine until, she got a warning at work..she was told to pick up her sales within 2 weeks or she's getting fired! So of course she started panicking and worrying, etc...she only wanted to stay home and never felt like going out..I would have to beg her to go out so I can see her...

After about 10 days of not seeing her and arguing a bit on the phone...she tells me the truth: for the past week me and my ex started talking again..she said she told him about work and the warning and that she told him because he is the person that knows her best...she told me that she realized that she still has feelings for him..the exact words were, "i really like you, but I still love my ex...I'm really confused..maybe we should take it easy for a while, take things slow"

I haven't talked to her in almost a week..let her miss me and realize what she is missing...she has a good thing with her here, don't know why she had to rekindle the past...giving her about 10 days-2 weeks to miss me...if she doesn't realize she made a mistake, I think I'm going to have to forget about her

My questions are: 1) is my decision good? 2) or do I just call her and fight for her...and tell her she is making a mistake, etc...basically, what will make me get her back...fighting for her, or making her miss me?

666 Answers
Romefalls19's Avatar
Romefalls19 Posts: 4,739, Reputation: 5721
Ultra Member
 
#131

Sep 10, 2008, 11:49 AM
I wouldn't call it pessimistic as much as I would expierence. From the 8 or 9 months I have been on this site, I have yet to hear a success story in where the girl went back after a break. I mean if you read through all the posts on this site, there aren't many success stories are there?
Helpful
tabbarat's Avatar
tabbarat Posts: 268, Reputation: 79
Full Member
 
#132

Sep 10, 2008, 11:56 AM
True...you have a point..the chances are slim..and that's why I say I'm not expecting anything...think of it this way, if I was scared of rejection and knew the chances were not to my favor, I would have walked away and saved myself some pain..BUT, instead I'm still in the game in a way...which either shows I'm really smart or really stupid :P....only one way to find out, and I'm willing to risk that for this girl (i only fall for a few girls)

And hey, there's a first time for everything
Helpful
talaniman's Avatar
talaniman Posts: 44,678, Reputation: 50641
Senior Family & People Expert
 
#133

Sep 10, 2008, 01:21 PM


I'm not pessimistic at all, and if you follow my posts, its about being healthy and realistic. Your female isn't the poor, helpless, confused, thing you think she is, and has her own motivations for doing things. My point is, make your decisions based on facts, and not feelings, because despite what females say, its their actions that reveal the true intentions. That with all us humans.

I also suspect there is something your not telling, because you seem mighty invested for a 4 month dating thing. Especially since a player like yourself is hung up on this female, and should know full well, it takes more than the feelings of one to make a relationship. As long as you play "the game" by her rules, you lose.

Quote:
Make HER decide to come back
Could this be about ego? Or you just have to prove you got it? I don't know, but you seem to spend way to much time trying to accomplish what? What does a player do when he gets what he wants?

He moves on, as there is no more thrill in the chase.
Helpful  (1)
Ash123's Avatar
Ash123 Posts: 1,794, Reputation: 1568
Ultra Member
 
#134

Sep 10, 2008, 02:09 PM
I think she's probably moved on.

But, I'm glad you can accept it and can be friends.
Helpful
tabbarat's Avatar
tabbarat Posts: 268, Reputation: 79
Full Member
 
#135

Sep 10, 2008, 02:47 PM
1) I disagree, she IS confused..but you are right, she also knows what she is doing...she doesn't want to decide on anything before she knows where her job puts her; stay in dubai or go back to ukraine for 6mnths

2) her actions tell me she still has feelings....no, scratch that..she TOLD me point blank she still likes me (during one of those long phone convos we had in which she didn't want me to hang up and kept flirting with me)...so there is no doubt there is still smthg there, or else I would have been out of the pic 3 weeks ago when the break up happened! I'm no fool, I don't waste my time on a girl that doesn't want me...but I know she still does

3) I like how your trying to analyze me :P....I never said I was a player..that is an ugly word...I just like being single, partying, meeting different girls, etc...most of my adult life has been single with dating girls for a max of one or two months..nothing special...I have only fell for 2 girls, my ex of 5yrs which ended because she wanted marriage and I wasn't ready yet, and now this ukranian girl for 4 months...the reason I'm so "invested" is because she has everything I want in a girl and more..we just click...we didn't fight once in 4 mnths! I can't explain it..but I have been in dubai for 1 year now...the 4mnths with her were better than the 8mnths I was single in! (mind you I had my first threesome during that time )...I rarely "invest" in a girl, but she was definitely worth my "money"

Its not about ego..trust me...she knows I can go out now and pick up a girl...some used to call me when I was with her..and she would see me ignore their calls...I don't have to prove anything to anyone...

And the chase is not over, the thrill is still there...because actually, now I realized how much she means to me

Hope I'm shedding light on why I care so much....all your advices are sound, and to be honest would probably give them myself to some poor sap on this webpage, but you guys have to be in my place to fully understand...I'm keeping my expectations low but am strong to handle whatever may result (i think)

As for ASH123: what makes you think she FULLY moved on?...and yeah, if all goes down the drain, I won't mind being friends with her..just like I'm still friends with my ex of 5yrs...when I told her that I want you to be happy even if its not with me, I really meant it because I do care about her purely
Helpful
liz28's Avatar
liz28 Posts: 4,660, Reputation: 5253
Ultra Member
 
#136

Sep 10, 2008, 03:29 PM
I know I stated I wasn't going comment anymore but I wanted to point something out to you.
First you say:sure she started talking to him again, and told me to take it slow..but it is no way a "break up", as is in just leave me alone.

Then you say: there is no doubt there is still smthg there, or else I would have been out of the pic 3 weeks ago when the break up happen.

Was there an actual break- or not?

First you say:she was the one who said she loved you first. Then you say, she only likes me. Which one was it?

Tal stated you were a player because you stated it in your eariler post. Now you say, player is a ungly word but yet you used it and associated it with your name.

Also, you can win someone heart when it is there to be won. What your going do win half or 1/4 of her heart?
Helpful
tabbarat's Avatar
tabbarat Posts: 268, Reputation: 79
Full Member
 
#137

Sep 10, 2008, 03:48 PM
1) Welcome back lizzie!

2) well, it WAS a break up in the sense we aren't together anymore...but NOT a break up in the sense that she still has feelings and is confused...when I break up with someone it means "leave me alone"..her break up was more of a "lets take it slow, give me time and space I am confused"...if I felt she didn't care about me anymore, I would have left 3 weeks ago

3) what I said was, until I left for vacation for 3 weeks...we used to tell each other I really like you, I really care about you, etc...one night she messaged me "i love u", and when I called her the next day, she said she was just feeling emotional because she missed me so much, but she wants to tell me it in person when I get back from my vacation...but we never got the chance...so lets say she really likes me and I really like her, but if things continued great with us (and she didn't get the warning at work), we definitely would be telling each other "i love u" now

4) I'm a player in the sense I like meeting different women and like to be single and party and travel...but NOT a player in the sense that I cheat on women and treat them badly and lie to them...never have, never will...in fact, the reason my relationships last 1-2 mnths is because I'm honest and break up with them first before I do smthg with someoen else...I have a younger sister, so I treat women the way I want guys to treat her..with respect and honesty

5) of course I want her full heart...I know she wasn't FULLY over her ex while she was with me, but she was moving on and things were amazing with us...UNTIL the warning at work, stress etc. Came and her past came back in the pic...so I want her back, then we'll go back to working on moving on and continuing where we stopped
Helpful
talaniman's Avatar
talaniman Posts: 44,678, Reputation: 50641
Senior Family & People Expert
 
#138

Sep 10, 2008, 04:12 PM


Quote:
all your advices are sound, and to be honest would probably give them myself to some poor sap on this webpage,
Thats just too condenscending, for a guy who is one of thousand trying to get their "girl" back.
Quote:
but you guys have to be in my place to fully understand
Its been a while for some of us, but you are far from unique. Especially on this forum.

You still hold on to confused huh! So be it.
Helpful
tabbarat's Avatar
tabbarat Posts: 268, Reputation: 79
Full Member
 
#139

Sep 10, 2008, 04:17 PM
No disrespect to anyone,in here I'm just like the rest of these guys..true

And yes, still hanging on to confused...because of all the examples I've said in my posts, because I'm the one living the situation, and because she told me straight out she still likes me..you have to trust me on this one...

If I was sure she FULLY wanted me out of her life or only FULLY as a friend, would have been gone long time ago my friend

Take care
Helpful
Ash123's Avatar
Ash123 Posts: 1,794, Reputation: 1568
Ultra Member
 
#140

Sep 11, 2008, 09:32 AM
Given all the facts: ukraine, old boyfriend, job stress, new culture, new place, "confusion" and flirting in bars.....she is clearly not serious. How old is she? 25? Has she gone to college? What is her relationship with her parents? What is her financial situation? What happened with her EX? How did they break up? How many friends does she have in dubai?

Since you have not had many serious girlfriends I know this feels really special - especially since she's making you work - but I am not sure yet this is too much.

Look at these questions and i'll see.

Also, what do you do?
Helpful  (1)

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.

Remove Text Formatting

Undo
Redo
 
Decrease Size
Increase Size
Bold
Italic
Underline
Align Left
Align Center
Align Right
Ordered List
Unordered List
Decrease Indent
Increase Indent
Insert Email Link
Wrap [QUOTE] tags around selected text
Wrap [CODE] tags around selected text
Wrap [HTML] tags around selected text
Wrap [PHP] tags around selected text
Wrap [YOUTUBE] tags around selected text
Notification Type:



Check out some similar questions!

The difference between "sex" and "love making" [ 13 Answers ]

Ok I have been answering questions on this site for just over a week now and I might add enjoyed it, but I am now interested in peoples views on the following. What is the difference between Sex and Love making? For many years I have had what I call Sex with my husband , sometimes good and...

I "Love You" but not "In Love With You" anymore... [ 9 Answers ]

Hi, A couple of days ago, my wife of the past 5+ years just dropped a total bomb on me. She told me that she wasn't "in love with me" anymore, but she still loves me, cares for me and doesn't want me to get hurt. A little history... We knew each other through other people for about...


View more Relationships questions Search