Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help!
Answer   ||    Advanced Search

Ask your question or search...
International Sites: Nederlandse experts vragen
User Name 
Password 
Join   Forgot password? 

Home > Society & Culture > Politics   »   Can Capitalism and Socialism co-exist? .

Question
 
 
Old Jun 30, 2007, 09:36 AM
Dark_crow's Avatar
Dark_crow
Ultra Member
Dark_crow is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: La Playa
Posts: 1,406
Dark_crow See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Dark_crow See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Can Capitalism and Socialism co-exist? .

My thinking is no, based on the following assumptions; what are yours?

Free market capitalism is based upon inherent individual rights while socialism is based on government-granted special privileges.

Reply With Quote
 
     

Answers
 
 
Old Jul 11, 2009, 03:45 PM   #21  
Full Member
paraclete is offline
 
paraclete's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 214
paraclete See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
I think all this problem of health care in the US is very sad and I say that from the perspective of a nation who gets universal health care for a tax surcharge of 1.5% on the higher earners and I also have health insurance because to beat the waiting lists in public hospitals you have to. The key to the system is controlling and moderating doctors fees and the cost of pharmacy. There is some disincentive but doctors are still among the highest earners so they don't really lose out and noone is placed in a situation of not being able to afford care and having to pay extortinate charges up front for care
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Jul 11, 2009, 06:49 PM   #22  
New Member
thePard is offline
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 7
thePard See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Hi Shady,

I did not hear that the insurance companies are being so co-operative with the uninsured.. My guess is that they are so freaked out by what has happened to financial institutions and the Auto companies, that they are rushing to present
their case before there is a rushed crisis vote on this again, but in the Senate.
If that happens, it will become law after the Prez signs it.

The problem with private insurance is the premiums and the exclusions for pre-existing conditions. If you are 18 to 35, and not employed by a big company with a good benefit plan, you are being soaked even though you may not use the insurance for any more than a childbirthing or two.
If you are at such a low risk of needing that insurance, people are smart enough to know that paying $5000 or more per year for family coverage is a rip off.
They would rather spend the money on a new vehicle or a trip to Disney World.

When you add to that, today's greatly reduced chances of landing a job that pays more than $30K a year, it is easy to see why so many do not bother with insurance unless they know that their health is going to fail soon.

A lot of people are fearful about government insurance because of the contract with
GE to handle the electronic record-keeping ( remember the last stimulus that was rushed through without being read?) That included $6 Billion to be used to set up the Electronic record system. (Nice of GE to be so co-operative)
Why is this feared? Simple.. If the Socialized Medicine should fail, will those
records end up in the hands of Private Insurance companies so that they can deny
coverage to bad risks?
Will the government safeguard that information, or will they sell it to the highest bidders anyway, even if they do maintain Socialized Medicine?

Will the government use the record system to police the bad habits of the obese,
the diabetic, the frequently injured, the smokers, ot just plain junk food consumption?
You say "how could this happen?" Simple... You compare the family's grocery
buying habits with their use of the medical system.
(Too many twinkies may spell early heart attacks.)
Will the purchase of ammunition link to death by hunting? Will hunting be
outlawed if it harms too many?




============================================


Quote:
Originally Posted by lshadylady View Post
I am not an expert. Are we about to see if Capitalism and Socialism can co-exist? Obahma's latest healthcare request is so not based on reality that I had hopes it would not pass. But even on these pages, there are ad's for people to come to the Health Care Insurance Companies for your free health care insurance. They are educating the public. The cost of supplemental insurance is $0 to $40 a month. The masses will pile on to them wanting and trusting that they are not paying with their lifestyle. but only $40 a month.

But what is unreal is they want to cut Medicare expenses to help pay for this insurance. The one thing that provides and gives many, many people healthcare that could not afford it otherwise. How can that work?

If the Insurance companies did not already know that putting this proposal to the vote was just a show, that it might not pass, would they spend the advertising money like this?

That's two questions . if that is not allowed leave out the Medicare statement, please.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Jul 12, 2009, 05:19 AM   #23  
Full Member
paraclete is offline
 
paraclete's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 214
paraclete See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
[quote=thePard;1849838]Hi Shady,

I did not hear that the insurance companies are being so co-operative with the uninsured.. My guess is that they are so freaked out by what has happened to financial institutions and the Auto companies, that they are rushing to present
their case before there is a rushed crisis vote on this again, but in the Senate.
If that happens, it will become law after the Prez signs it.

The problem with private insurance is the premiums and the exclusions for pre-existing conditions. If you are 18 to 35, and not employed by a big company with a good benefit plan, you are being soaked even though you may not use the insurance for any more than a childbirthing or two.
If you are at such a low risk of needing that insurance, people are smart enough to know that paying $5000 or more per year for family coverage is a rip off.
They would rather spend the money on a new vehicle or a trip to Disney World.

When you add to that, today's greatly reduced chances of landing a job that pays more than $30K a year, it is easy to see why so many do not bother with insurance unless they know that their health is going to fail soon.

A lot of people are fearful about government insurance because of the contract with
GE to handle the electronic record-keeping ( remember the last stimulus that was rushed through without being read?) That included $6 Billion to be used to set up the Electronic record system. (Nice of GE to be so co-operative)
Why is this feared? Simple.. If the Socialized Medicine should fail, will those
records end up in the hands of Private Insurance companies so that they can deny
coverage to bad risks?
Will the government safeguard that information, or will they sell it to the highest bidders anyway, even if they do maintain Socialized Medicine?

Will the government use the record system to police the bad habits of the obese,
the diabetic, the frequently injured, the smokers, ot just plain junk food consumption?
You say "how could this happen?" Simple... You compare the family's grocery
buying habits with their use of the medical system.
(Too many twinkies may spell early heart attacks.)
Will the purchase of ammunition link to death by hunting? Will hunting be
outlawed if it harms too many?

Can I say your post appears very paranoid. To think that the information might be misused is not a good reason for everyone not to get health care. yes, it is possible but you are talking of a conspiracy on an unprecedented scale.

In the system I live in, there is no overt use of the data to modify patient behaviour, but there might be monitoring to modify physician behaviour, such as observing and curbing overbilling. The reality is there must be trust, trust that the patient will observe the charges made, and query if needed, and trust that the physician is generally honest and not interested in gaming the system, you also have to trust the government, trust that they generally do want the best possible care to be provided. Don't give up the possibility of improvement for millions because you don't trust the existing system. Take the profit incentive out of medicine and you will get a better outcome.
  Reply With Quote
 
     

Your Answer
Email me when someone replies to my answer
Join Login



Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes
Ask your question or search...



Similar Threads
Does random exist
(6 replies)
Does Truth Exist?
(33 replies)
Do ghost dolls really exist?
(10 replies)
the one may truly not exist.
(5 replies)
The guy I like doesnt know I exist.
(3 replies)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page
Search this Thread

Advanced Search

Bookmarks





Copyright ©2003 - 2009, Ask Me Help Desk.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:35 AM.