Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
    Dolly2010's Avatar
    Dolly2010 Posts: 1, Reputation: 1
    New Member
     
    #1

    Jul 19, 2010, 06:26 AM
    dispute medical bill
    A month ago I was suffering from severe pain that started in my back and radiated to my lower abdomen. It was so severe I went to our local ER. By the time I got there (1/2hour drive), and waited to be seen by the ER doctor (ER was busy), the pain had mostly subsided. I explained the symptoms. I was asked to describe the pain on a level of 1 to 10. I said the pain had subsided, but I would have rated it as a 10 at the time I called to say I was coming in. The ER doctor ordered a blood test, they took my blood pressure and temperature, and he decided I was having a flare from ulcerative colitis (a condition I have, which has been pretty much under control for a few years). I explained to him that the symptoms were not the same as when I have had flares in the past (they come on slowly, not in one day). I explained to him that I have never had that type nor that severe pain in the past. He ignored me, prescribed a high dose of prednisone for six days, and offered me valium (which I did not accept). I decided to go home, try to make it through the weekend (this was late Friday night), and try to contact my GI specialist on Monday and ask what they thought. The next day the pain came back again, just as bad and for a longer period. In the end, I made two more ER visits (different ER), and it turned out I had a large kidney stone that was lodged. When I went in again, I was very dehydrated, low blood pressure, very low potassium, vomiting, etc.

    Now, the bills are starting to come. My first ER bill, from the hospital that misdiagnosed me, didn't listen to me, and sent me home... is the highest. It is MUCH higher than the second ER visit. In the second ER visit, I was there several hours, had x-rays, a CT scan, morphine, constant monitoring, blood work, nurses attending me, and several visits from the ER doctor. I don't have the third ER visit bills yet to compare, there I was actually admitted for observation for two days, so I expect they will be higher.

    My question is... I think the first ER bill is outrageous, plus I was misdiagnosed, and feel I was dismissed by the doctor. Do I have a right to dispute this bill? If yes, what would be the process for doing so?
    JudyKayTee's Avatar
    JudyKayTee Posts: 46,503, Reputation: 4600
    Uber Member
     
    #2

    Jul 19, 2010, 06:41 AM

    If you don't pay they will take you to Small Claims Court. Pay under protest and then sue THEM in Small Claims Court. Keep in mind that the hospital has costs when someone is in the ER and those are passed along.
    J_9's Avatar
    J_9 Posts: 40,298, Reputation: 5646
    Expert
     
    #3

    Jul 19, 2010, 06:44 AM

    Firstly, the ER does not necessarily diagnose (for the most part, but treats emergent patients). Switching from hospital to hospital makes it appear as drug/attention seeking behavior (just thought you might like to know that for future reference).

    My first thought was kidney stones as well, however, since the pain had subsided prior to being seen, the doctor has to take past medical into account when "diagnosing" in the ER.

    Now, every hospital has different charges, somewhat even though they all have to go through what is called a DRG.

    If the first hospital you went to was a private hospital, well their charges are going to be higher.

    From what it sounds like, your level of pain as well as the description, was not enough to warrant an ultrasound of the kidneys. So, then the doctor has to treat according to presenting symptoms.

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 

Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.


Check out some similar questions!

Can an employer ask about medical background based on a past due medical bill? [ 1 Answers ]

Can an employer question the nature of a medical bill or your medical background based on a past due medical bill on your credit report?

How to dispute doctor's bill [ 9 Answers ]

Hello I took my son for vision exam. The appointment lasts 5 min, doctor just checked his vision using the chart on the wall. Later we received $185 bill for COMPREHENSIVE EYE EXAM!! The same thing happened to my friends and their children, $185 for 5 min exam! This is a complete fraud!...

Medical Bill Dispute [ 2 Answers ]

I went to the emergency room in great pain and told every person I met what I needed. I had had a tummy tuck in Costa Rico and my tummy was so full of fluid I could barely walk. My tummy needed to be drained. When I finally saw the doctor, she said," We don't do that." She gave me a referral to an...

Phone Bill dispute [ 11 Answers ]

Hi, I just recently came across an issue that Im struggling with, and I hope that someone will have advice for me. I currently have cell phone service through a national cellular provider, and I normally paid my bill online. Last September I was short $27 for my bill, so I asked a friend to...


View more questions Search