Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help!
  Advanced
Register  |  Log in  
   Ask    
 Answer  
  Help  

Ask QuestionsprogressAnswer QuestionsprogressBuild ReputationprogressBecome an Expert
 
Free Answers in 3 Easy Steps

Register Now
3 Steps

At Ask Me Help Desk you can ask questions in any topic and have them answered for free by our experts. To ask questions or participate in answering them you must register for a free account. By registering you will be able to:
  • Get free answers from experts in any of our 300+ topics.
  • Accept money for answers that you provide.
  • Communicate privately with other members (PM).
  • See fewer ads.

Home > Law > Other Law   »   challenging a law

 
Question Tools Search this Question Display Modes
Question
 
 
#1  
Old Oct 14, 2006, 08:12 AM
GaryArt
Junior Member
GaryArt is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 43
GaryArt See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
challenging a law

How would I go about challenging the legality/constitutionality of a law or statute?

What type of action would I bring to challenge a newly-enacted Federal statute?

Who should I name as parties?

Mainly, I want (a) an injunction preventing enforcement (immediately, and during the case), and (b) declaratory relief establishing that the law is unconstitutional and void (permamently).

I know a little bit about law, and I know my way around the courthouse (filings, etc., but this is a little beyond what I've been imvolved wth before. I'd appreciate any guidance, suggestions, advice, etc.

Thx.

Reply With Quote
 
     

Answers
 
 
Old Oct 14, 2006, 09:02 AM   #2  
mr.yet
Bankruptcy & Debt Expert
mr.yet is offline
 
mr.yet's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: republic of maryland
Posts: 1,615
mr.yet See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.mr.yet See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Visit is site it may help you understand how to

link:
http://www.suijuris.net/
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Oct 14, 2006, 09:28 AM   #3  
excon
Ultra Member
excon is offline
 
excon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: On the outside
Posts: 8,107
excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.excon See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Hello Gary:

There may be a path that a citizen can use, WITHOUT there first being a case. I wouldn't know how to do that. Maybe a citizen’s initiative?

Nonetheless, challenges to law are taken up in the courts AFTER a case has been brought where the government (or somebody) acted contrary to the Constitution (or at least the petitioner/appellant hopes so).

Of course, Congress can repeal a law, but they're not gonna do that.

excon

PS> So, whatever law you want to challenge, go get yourself arrested for it, and bingo, you're on your way.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Oct 14, 2006, 11:49 AM   #4  
Fr_Chuck
Christianity Expert
Fr_Chuck is offline
 
Fr_Chuck's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Atlanta GA
Posts: 23,654
Fr_Chuck has disabled reputation
You have to have a standing to the law.

For example if you want to challegne a law on abortion ban, you would have to want an abortion and be denied, then you file a law suit in federal court.

If the law does not effect you, you can not bring suit against it.

Of course you will have to sue and it will have to go to the supreme court to be heard. And it will cost 10's of thousands of dollars just to file and have copies of all the paper work for the justicies
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Oct 14, 2006, 08:05 PM   #5  
s_cianci
Ultra Member
s_cianci is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Eastern Seaboard - USA
Posts: 4,545
s_cianci See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.s_cianci See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.s_cianci See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.s_cianci See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.s_cianci See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.s_cianci See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
What has your attorney advised? If (s)he believes the law(s) in question are unconstitutional then (s)he'll build your defense around that premise. Whether or not the judge will agree is a whole other matter. If you lose you can always appeal on the same grounds. Most declarations of a law being unconstitutional occur in the higher courts as a result of appeals.
  Reply With Quote
 
     
 
 
Old Oct 15, 2006, 04:10 AM   #6  
ScottGem
Computer Expert
ScottGem is offline
 
ScottGem's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: LI, NY - USA
Posts: 21,901
ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.ScottGem See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Pay to call ScottGem for advice ($.75/min)
Call ScottGem via Skype™
Step 1 is to be convicted or denied action under the law. I don't believe that being unconstitutional is grounds for a defense against the initial action. As I understand it, lower courts don't have the right to rule on constitutionality. That's the province of the Appeals Courts.

Once you are convicted or denied some action, you then start the appeals process on the grounds that the law is unconstitutional. The case winds its way thru the judiciary eventually reaching the Supreme Court. Any ruling they make is final.

You might try contacting your local ACLU office if you feel strongly about it.

I'm just curious as to what statute you beleive is unconstitutional.
  Reply With Quote
 
     


Question Tools Search this Question
Search this Question:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

 
Similar Sponsors

Similar Questions
Question Asker Topic Answers Last Post
What's the law? Luv_My_Reece Family Law 4 Aug 17, 2006 08:04 PM
law HoNee Crime 1 Feb 26, 2006 06:54 PM
the LAW Paul_Donald Corporate Law 1 Dec 26, 2004 02:23 PM
Law Paul_Donald Other Law 0 Aug 24, 2004 04:36 AM
challenging question curioso Music 0 Dec 25, 2003 09:51 PM




Copyright ©2003 - 2007, Ask Me Help Desk.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:42 PM.

Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6 © 2006, Crawlability, Inc.