Your not going to like me but if that insulation gets 5% of moisture in it it looses 95% of its insul properties.
Two major things go wrong with a cathedral ceiling is 1. not enough rafter thickness to obtain the proper (R) value for its Geo. 2. Is the venting from the soffit to full ridge vent is not addressed well to keep the min 2" air space in each rafter bay to stop moisture build. 3. Moisture barrier is so crucial in close applications on cathedral and if that was not used then again moisture.
Hear is a Geo map for (R) values. If you need (R) 30 then the rafter solidi be a 2x12 for 91/4" insulation and the the air space full rafter width in each joist bay.
EERE Energy Savers: Insulation What is insulation R value? | Insulation | Insulation Info
My question is how long have you had this house and did you have any Ice Dams on the edges of the roof which can also create your problem that showed up. Ice dams are also the direct result of poor or low insulation at the roofs edges by the eves.
Signed 21 Boat
If I Helped To Answer Your Question Please Rate My Answer