Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask
Help!

I've liked this girl (we're both in our early twenties) for almost a year now, but the entire time she had a boyfriend (for 1 year and a half). We live 2 hours drive away, but her boyfriend lives in the same city. I have no idea how they are doing, but it is her first boyfriend.

For the past year, we've kept in touch pretty well. We talked on the phone at least once a week for a few hours. We emailed every second day. And when I'm in town, we would go out just the two of us.

A few weeks ago I told her how I felt. Basically, to summarize the important parts of the conversation, I said: "I really like you, but I know you have a boyfriend, so I tried so hard to fight off the feelings but I just can't." She said: "I don't know what to say, but thank you for telling me"... And then we hung up.

It's been 3-4 weeks now and we did not really speak much since that day. I've been giving her space and time to digest what I said and hopefully she will say something back.

Then, two days ago, I couldn't take it and I called her up. We just talked like normal and then I asked her if she was free this weekend. I just wanted to hang out with her, I was not planning to bring up my feelings for her. She said she might go out of town. But if she is in town, she will let me know. I find out tonight.

At this moment, this is exactly how I feel and what I want to say to her:
I am the type of person who would go after what I want. I do not sit around and wait for something to happen.

But I also know that sometimes, there are restrictions beyond my control. For example, it does not matter how I feel about you, the fact remains that you have a boyfriend.

I respect that and I really hope that you are happy. But there is so much I want to say and do but I cannot. I cannot even tell you how much I like you or even why I like you.

At first, I wanted to know how you feel about me too. But since you have a boyfriend, it is better if you do not say anything. I do not want to ruin your relationship.

Because I know that nothing can happen between us, I feel so much pain. Part of me wants to stay friends with you because I rather you be part of my life than nothing at all. But at the same time, staying friends with you will remind me of the pain.
Obviously I cannot say 90% of those things. What do I do?

I know the reality is that I have to move on. Here's an analogy of how it feels. It feels like I will fail an exam because I am not allowed to show up. I won't even get a chance to write the exam. I know that I should have dropped the course, but I missed the deadline. It's too late to drop, I like her too much.

128 Answers
I wish's Avatar
I wish Posts: 5,256, Reputation: 10093
Family & People Expert
 
#41

Mar 7, 2009, 05:37 AM


UPDATE:

This completely caught me off guard and it seems way too good to be true. I found out last night that she changed her status on Facebook. She took her link with her boyfriend off. So now that part is blank, as in nothing in the status section. As for the boyfriend, it still says "In a relationship" but with no one linked to it. I guess he has to change that part off himself.

I don't want to get my hopes up or get ahead of myself because I haven't gotten any news from her directly. Just to be cautious, is it possible that she suddendly decided to hide her relationship of 1.5 year?

As for me, I think I will just continue to talk to her normally as if I knew nothing. If she does confirm it one day, I know that I can only be her friend for a while because I don't want to be her rebound...

Anything else I need to keep in mind about?
Helpful
kctiger's Avatar
kctiger Posts: 3,631, Reputation: 6566
Ultra Member
 
#42

Mar 7, 2009, 06:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by I wish View Post
UPDATE:

This completely caught me off guard and it seems way too good to be true. I found out last night that she changed her status on Facebook. She took her link with her boyfriend off. So now that part is blank, as in nothing in the status section. As for the boyfriend, it still says "In a relationship" but with no one linked to it. I guess he has to change that part off himself.

I don't want to get my hopes up or get ahead of myself because I haven't gotten any news from her directly. Just to be cautious, is it possible that she suddendly decided to hide her relationship of 1.5 year?

As for me, I think I will just continue to talk to her normally as if I knew nothing. If she does confirm it one day, I know that I can only be her friend for a while because I don't want to be her rebound...

Anything else I need to keep in mind about?
Well, if it is changed on Facebook, then it must be official, someone alert the press...

Dude, you sound like an absolute creeper right now...listen to yourself. You would be a rebound IF she decided to come to you AFTER she broke up with her boyfriend. Get your thumb out of your a$$ and quit acting like a freaking dog...your tail is wagging after reading her "status" on FB isn't it?
Helpful  (1)
friend4u178's Avatar
friend4u178 Posts: 3,452, Reputation: 7927
Ultra Member
 
#43

Mar 7, 2009, 12:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by I wish View Post
UPDATE:

This completely caught me off guard and it seems way too good to be true. I found out last night that she changed her status on Facebook. She took her link with her boyfriend off. So now that part is blank, as in nothing in the status section. As for the boyfriend, it still says "In a relationship" but with no one linked to it. I guess he has to change that part off himself.

I don't want to get my hopes up or get ahead of myself because I haven't gotten any news from her directly. Just to be cautious, is it possible that she suddendly decided to hide her relationship of 1.5 year?

As for me, I think I will just continue to talk to her normally as if I knew nothing. If she does confirm it one day, I know that I can only be her friend for a while because I don't want to be her rebound...

Anything else I need to keep in mind about?
Your falling for the Demon of FALSE HOPE !
Helpful  (2)
HistorianChick's Avatar
HistorianChick Posts: 2,556, Reputation: 4132
Ultra Member
 
#44

Mar 7, 2009, 02:27 PM
As much as I love Facebook, it is the absolute worst thing ever for people recovering from a breakup and those wanting something they can't or shouldn't have.

Just leave the girl alone and let her make up her own mind.

Seriously. That's the best thing to do!
Helpful  (2)
heartbroke's Avatar
heartbroke Posts: 163, Reputation: 115
Junior Member
 
#45

Mar 17, 2009, 12:18 AM
Any updates I wish?
Helpful
I wish's Avatar
I wish Posts: 5,256, Reputation: 10093
Family & People Expert
 
#46

Mar 18, 2009, 05:53 AM


UPDATE:

First off, I wanted to thank everyone for their help. I really took everyone's opinion into consideration, as appreciative as I may have sounded.

About a week ago, she confirmed with me that she broke up with her boyfriend. She also told me that she hasd a job interview for a job in my city (we live 2 hours away). As she is already aware of my feelings, I didn't want to be the rebound guy (I didn't say this, but I was thinking it). So I told her that I was going to give her "time and space before contacting her again. But that I will be there for her if she just wanted to talk to a regular friend."

Instead, she told me that she broke up with her boyfriend for mutiple reasons and one of the reasons was that she wanted to concentrate on her studies and that I should not waste my time on her anymore. She told me to focus on my career and that she hopes to stay friends.

That was the last straw. It is still extremely painful and I'm trying my best to move on. I've never felt so much pain... I've even had two medium-term relationships (2 years and 3 years) and like quite a number of other girls, but I've never been so hurt and we've never even been together. Is this even possible?
Helpful
ordinaryguy's Avatar
ordinaryguy Posts: 1,795, Reputation: 3046
Ultra Member
 
#47

Mar 18, 2009, 09:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by I wish View Post
Instead, she told me that she broke up with her boyfriend for mutiple reasons and one of the reasons was that she wanted to concentrate on her studies and that I should not waste my time on her anymore. She told me to focus on my career and that she hopes to stay friends.
Ooohh, that's a chill wind blowin', man! How considerate of her to be concerned about a waste of YOUR time!

Actually, she did the honorable thing to make it clear that she doesn't want a romantic relationship with you, boyfriend or no boyfriend. You should thank her for that.

Quote:
That was the last straw.
The sooner you really accept this, the sooner you'll start to heal. Illusions lose their power when they're accepted for what they are. She's not that into you, man. Sorry.

Yes, these asymmetric obsessions are a b!tch, it's true, but they seem to be a nearly universal human experience. I take that to mean they're a necessary part of our emotional education for adulthood. Suck it up, kid. Honestly, you'll be fine and I wish you well.
Helpful  (2)
I wish's Avatar
I wish Posts: 5,256, Reputation: 10093
Family & People Expert
 
#48

Mar 18, 2009, 10:34 AM
The way you put it, is it even worth being friends with her?

It's such a sad and pathetic feeling right now... I'm sure in time I will heal. Like I said, everything else in my life seems to be going alright. I know that I can't let one girl bring me down like this. But does it ever feel horrible.
Helpful
talaniman's Avatar
talaniman Posts: 44,360, Reputation: 50366
Senior Family & People Expert
 
#49

Mar 18, 2009, 02:22 PM
Quote:
I wish;1612164, The way you put it, is it even worth being friends with her?
Don't even think about that, until you have gotten past this whole situation, however long it takes.
Quote:
It's such a sad and pathetic feeling right now...
I agree, break ups thoroughly suck!
Quote:
I'm sure in time I will heal.
Absolutely!
Quote:
Like I said, everything else in my life seems to be going alright. I know that I can't let one girl bring me down like this.
Thats something to remember. Even as you have those dark days, know the sun will shine again.
Helpful
I wish's Avatar
I wish Posts: 5,256, Reputation: 10093
Family & People Expert
 
#50

Mar 18, 2009, 02:52 PM
Thanks for your support.

This pain I'm feeling is outrageous. When we feel depressed, we feel pessimistic about every aspect of our lives. But I'm only feeling this way about the girl, like I said, every thing else in my life is going pretty well. So all the pain is concentrated on her, so it's really really really INTENSE. I can't even think of words to describe this feeling.

I don't know how to tone the intensity down. It makes no sense whatsoever. Where is the off switch?
Helpful

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search



Check out some similar questions!

This girl I like has a Boyfriend. [ 5 Answers ]

I really like this girl who's my workmate. She has a boyfriend for 4 months now but I know her before her boyfriend does. I only know her by her name by just only last year. But now that she's new at work and I see her again we actually get to know each other better and got a lot closer, Mutual...

I'm a girl, I kissed a girl, I didn't like it. Should I tell my boyfriend? [ 10 Answers ]

Me and my boyfriend are 19.. He's not a partier but sometimes I can be. I used to party and drink every other weekend before we started going out but I stopped when I started dating him because he didn't really like it unless he was around. Plus he doesn't want me doing anything that's bad for me...

This girl I like has a boyfriend [ 9 Answers ]

Hello, I was jogging the other day and ran into an attractive girl. We stopped and said hi and both complimented each other. It turns out she lives right down the street. She gave me her # and said she wanted to work out with me. She came over twice so far and all we did was talk and work out...

I like this girl but she has a boyfriend [ 2 Answers ]

Hey everyone I'm jason, I'm a junior in high school. I really like this girl and I think she likes me too We text a lot and I get her out of class at least once a week and we just walk around school and talk. My brother has a class with her and she talks about me with him. I don't know where...

I like a girl that has a boyfriend [ 13 Answers ]

Ok so there is this girl I really like but she has a boyfriend her and her boyfriend have been together quite a while I have told this girl that I like her but she said that we could just be friends so if I did ask her out she would say no and her boyfriend would get pretty angry should I ask this...


View more Dating questions Search