Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help !
Ask

Is it a misdemeanor or felony?

Asked May 10, 2012, 03:36 PM — 11 Answers
My child an adult lives at my house this child intercepted a credit card which came through the mail and activated it and made 15 charges on it and only stopped using it when it was maxed out. Lucky for me the credit limit was very small $700 . I called it in to the police now I've heard rumors that ea of those 15 charges is considered a new crime so my child will have 15 counts against her. Then I heard each count (charge) is a felony, even the lowest one $1.59.

So will there be 15 counts against her, will they be misdemeanors or felonies? Even though I called in the police report and I called the police to come to one of the merchants, where she used the card I haven't given them any more information once I heard that ea charge is a separate count, and that they could be felonies. So if I pay the card off what could happen to her?

11 Answers
Fr_Chuck's Avatar
Fr_Chuck Posts: 72,965, Reputation: 37216
Expert
 
#2

May 10, 2012, 08:15 PM


Where you live makes a difference, each state in the US has different laws on credit card theft or fraud.

Yes, they may do 15 separate charges, in that case, most likely each will be a misdemeanor.

If they do one charge ( which I see is more likely) it can be a felony in some US states. In others it would not be enough money.

There is other issues, since with 15 charges, the judge and/or DA could ask for each sentence to be ran one after the other, not at the same time.

Either way it can be serious depending on how the DA wants to go after it.
Helpful
tater295's Avatar
tater295 Posts: 6, Reputation: 4
New Member
 
#3

May 12, 2012, 11:52 PM
15 misdemeanors, 15 felonys
I asked this ques. last week and received one answer which was somewhat ambiguous due to the fact that I did not tell where I live so now I will clarify I live in Orange County, California. A credit card came in my mail for me; my adult child who lives with me intercepted the card and activated it. They made 15 charges on it and than it was maxed out. It had a small limit $700. I called it in to the police now I've heard rumors that each of those 15 charges are considered a seperate offense. Than I heard each count (charge) is a felony, even the lowest one $1.59.

So will there be 15 counts against her, will they be misdemeanors or felonies? Even though I called in the police report and I called the police to come to one of the merchants, where she used the card I haven't given them anymore information once I heard that ea. charge is a separate count, and that they could be felonies. So if I pay the card off what could happen to her?
Helpful
excon's Avatar
excon Posts: 21,042, Reputation: 15510
Expert
 
#4

May 13, 2012, 04:33 AM


Quote:
Originally Posted by tater295 View Post
So if I pay the card off what could happen to her?
Hello tater:

Couple things... You got YOUR credit rating... And, you got your daughter... If you want to save your credit rating, you'll pay off the card.. The rating agencies don't really care about your domestic problems..

Next is the criminal charges.. I can't believe they'll charge her with a felony for each individual charge... But, you can't STOP them no matter WHAT you do. Paying off the card won't do it. The best thing you can do is hire a good lawyer for your daughter.

excon
Helpful  (1)
tater295's Avatar
tater295 Posts: 6, Reputation: 4
New Member
 
#5

May 13, 2012, 04:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by excon View Post
hello tater:

Couple things... You got your credit rating... And, you got your daughter... If you want to save your credit rating, you'll pay off the card.. The rating agencies don't really care about your domestic problems..

Next is the criminal charges.. I can't believe they'll charge her with a felony for each individual charge... But, you can't stop them no matter what you do. Paying off the card won't do it. The best thing you can do is hire a good lawyer for your daughter.

Excon
i know some things you said are incorrect one they cannot charge me for charges made by another adult commiting fraud. Two. If i pay it off it will prevent the police from being able to cite her for the charges they have no details of . So please someone answer my question someone with a background in law not a background in getting caught by the law (excon)
excon (May 13, 2012 05:36 AM): NA   Source:
ScottGem (May 13, 2012 05:44 AM): What you think you know is actually incorrect.   Source:standard criminal law
Helpful
ScottGem's Avatar
ScottGem Posts: 58,578, Reputation: 28375
Computer Expert and Renaissance Man
 
#6

May 13, 2012, 05:43 AM


Quote:
Originally Posted by tater295 View Post
i know some things you said are incorrect one they cannot charge me for charges made by another adult commiting fraud. Two. If i pay it off it will prevent the police from being able to cite her for the charges they have no details of . So please someone answer my question someone with a background in law not a background in getting caught by the law (excon)
First, I merged your two threads.

And excon is not wrong here. Criminal charges are prosecuted by the "state", not be individuals. Once a crime is reported it is up to the prosecutor's office to decide how to pursue the case. If you pay the bill, that doesn't remove the crime and the prosecutor could still choose to prosecute. It mght be unlikely but they can.

Second, Yes, they CAN charge you for the charges on the account unless fraud can be proven. So if you withdraw the criminal charges, you can be held responsible for the charges against the account.

Finally, your remark to excon was uncalled for. Many people who have been caught by the law become quite expert in it. excon is a respected member of this site and has prove his expertise over the years.
Helpful
AK lawyer's Avatar
AK lawyer Posts: 10,076, Reputation: 4242
Expert
 
#7

May 13, 2012, 06:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tater295 View Post
i know some things you said are incorrect one they cannot charge me for charges made by another adult commiting fraud. ...
That is true. But Excon didn't suggest that they could charge you. Please re-read what he wrote.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ScottGem View Post
...
Second, Yes, they CAN charge you for the charges on the account unless fraud can be proven. So if you withdraw the criminal charges, you can be held responsible for the charges against the account.
...
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you mean that the credit card company can and will expect you to pay. OP would not be guilty of a crime.
Helpful
ScottGem's Avatar
ScottGem Posts: 58,578, Reputation: 28375
Computer Expert and Renaissance Man
 
#8

May 13, 2012, 08:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AK lawyer View Post
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you mean that the credit card company can and will expect you to pay. OP would not be guilty of a crime.
Yes, Because the word "charges" has a dual meaning here I tried to make it clear. The OP is not guilty of a crime. However, the OP could be held responsible for the balance on the account. Since the charges were made by a family member, unless the OP press criminal charges against the family member, the credit card issuer might not believe the credit card purchases were made fraudulently.
Helpful
excon's Avatar
excon Posts: 21,042, Reputation: 15510
Expert
 
#9

May 13, 2012, 08:23 AM
Hello again,

The OP seems to think that if she REPORTS the purchases as fraud, she won't have to pay... That's true, but when the fraud division of the bank discovers that the daughter made the purchases, THEY'LL press criminal charges, because THEY'RE now the victim. They'll replace the money in the OP's account, but the daughter is going to be charged - if NOT by the bank, by the cops who she evidently called.

Look. She's confused, and isn't very nice... No wonder the daughter ripped her off.

excon
Helpful
tater295's Avatar
tater295 Posts: 6, Reputation: 4
New Member
 
#10

May 13, 2012, 08:42 AM
LETS GET BACK TO THE ISSUE MY 32 YEAR OLD INTERCEPTED THE CARD IN THE MAIL I NEVER SAW IT .I WAS FURIOUS I CALLED THE POLICE I THAN WENT TO A MERCHANT WHO SPENT 2 HRS DOINGMY CHILDS HAIR 4 DAYS BEFORE I DISCOVERED THE FRAUD THAT HAIRDRESSER REMEMBERED MY CHILD AND DESCRIBED HER TO A TEE, HER CELL NUM. WAS USED TO ACTIVATE THE CARD. A FEW CHARGES WERE ONLY A FEW DOLLARS I WAS TOLD THAT ALL 15 CHARGES FRAUDULENTLY MADE WILL BE TREATED AS 15 DIFFERENT CHARGES. i TOLD YOU I LIVE IN CALIF. NO ONE HAS ANSWERED THE QUESTION;WHICH IS "IS IT TRUE THAT THESE 15 SEPARATE COUNTS WILL BE 15 FELONIES. IF YOU READ WHAT I WROTE YOU WOULD KNOW IT IS JIBERISH TO SAY I COULD BE CHARGED WITH THE FRAUD,I TOLD YOU THEY DESCRIBED THE CULPRIT A FEMALE NOT ME A DAD. THEY KNOW IT WASN'T MY PH. NUMBER. THAT WAS USED TO ACTIVATE THE CARD. AS FAR AS THE FELLOW THAT THINKS HE KNOWS THE LAW AND BELIGERENTLY THREW IN THAT MY CREDIT SCORE COULD BE AFFECTED IF I DON'T PAY ON BEHALF OF THE ADULT THAT COMMITTED FRAUD I SUGGEST HIM TO GO STUDY NOW CAN ANYONE JUST ANSWER THE QUESTION 15 FELONIES OR 15 MISDEMEANORS TOTAL OF ALL CHARGES $700 SINGLE HIGHEST CHARGE $145.00 IF THE LAW CAN IMPOSE 15 FELONIES FOR THIS CAPER AND 3 FELONIES FOR 3 CHARGES OF A FEW BUCKS EACH I'D BE AMAAZED DON'T ANYONE KNOW THE ANSWER I'M CERTAIN YOU HAVE ALL THE FACTS NEEDED TO ANSWER.
Helpful  (1)

Not your question? Ask your question View similar questions

 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Add your answer here.

Remove Text Formatting

Undo
Redo
 
Decrease Size
Increase Size
Bold
Italic
Underline
Align Left
Align Center
Align Right
Ordered List
Unordered List
Decrease Indent
Increase Indent
Insert Email Link
Wrap [QUOTE] tags around selected text
Wrap [CODE] tags around selected text
Wrap [HTML] tags around selected text
Wrap [PHP] tags around selected text
Wrap [YOUTUBE] tags around selected text
Notification Type:



Check out some similar questions!

Is a Court Martial a Felony or Misdemeanor or Felony [ 6 Answers ]

Is a Court Martial a Felony or Misdemeanor or Felony. I see many questions on this topic...please post my input. A summary Court Martial is not a felony conviction period! There is nothing in the military to equate a Court Martial to a felony or misdemeanor conviction. The federal courts look...

Felony or Misdemeanor [ 0 Answers ]

I was sentenced to two years probation for aggravated battery with intent. I completed the probation and was released by signature order of the DA's office that prosecuted me. However, two months after starting my probation a restitution hearing was held. Niether my probation office nor mself were...

Felony or Misdemeanor? [ 3 Answers ]

Is wrongful use of cocaine a felony or misdemeanor it was a result from a special court martial so its a federal conviction. I have done a lot of research, I have asked public defenders, attorneys and even military lawyers but I have not gotten an answer? I have heard New jersey justifies any...

I need 2 know if this is a misdemeanor or a felony in GA [ 1 Answers ]

Stealing a bank card & withdrawing $300.00 out of an atm, is it a misdemeanor or felony in the state of GA

Misdemeanor or Felony? [ 1 Answers ]

Is a probation violation a felony or a misdemeanor?


View more Criminal Law questions Search