I understand how it works, thanks

lol
I had a similar situation with a video that was posted on my comments page. In my case, the Delete Comment button was switched around in a way that when i tried to delete the video (since it, too, was pushing other comments below it), it would actually delete a comment that I wasnt trying to delete.
The reason why knowing the profile would help is because you can select to View All Comments and then view the source code and determine what is going on.