Ask Experts Questions for FREE Help!
Ask    ||    Answer
 
Advanced  
 

Ask QuestionsprogressAnswer QuestionsprogressBuild ReputationprogressBecome an Expert
 
Free Answers in 3 Easy Steps

Register Now
3 Steps

At Ask Me Help Desk you can ask questions in any topic and have them answered for free by our experts. To ask questions or participate in answering them you must register for a free account. By registering you will be able to:
  • Get free answers from experts in any of our 300+ topics.
  • Accept money for answers that you provide.
  • Communicate privately with other members (PM).
  • See fewer ads.

Home > Society & Culture > Religion > Christianity   »   Scripture & Tradition

 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Question
 
 
#1  
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:18 PM
Akoue
Ultra Member
Akoue is offline
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,098
Akoue See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Akoue See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Scripture & Tradition

Early Christians regarded Tradition as coming from God no less than did Scripture itself. And yet, in the long march of time from those early centuries, many have come to regard Tradition as a foe, as something opposed to Scripture. There is a reasoned case to be made for both views. My question is, which view is correct, and why? The question has two parts, and I am interested to hear answers to either or both.
1. Is revealed truth limited to Scripture?
2. What role, if any, does Tradition have in allowing us to understand Scripture?

Please: Kindly support any response you care to share with reasoned support. In other words, please do not simply post dizzying lists of Scriptural passages. For any Scripture you do offer, please provide some explanation of what you take it to be saying and why you take it to say that.

Thank you in advance.

 
     

Answers
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:23 PM   #2  
Über Member
N0help4u is offline
 
N0help4u's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: dark side of moon, Pa
Posts: 16,919
N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Send a message via Yahoo to N0help4u
Some traditions are good and some are not
You have to look at the context and the history
where did it come from
Does it line up with scripture
Is it man's tradition because they believe it will please God
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:38 PM   #3  
Senior Member
JoeT777 is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 888
JoeT777 See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Akoue View Post
Early Christians regarded Tradition as coming from God no less than did Scripture itself. And yet, in the long march of time from those early centuries, many have come to regard Tradition as a foe, as something opposed to Scripture. There is a reasoned case to be made for both views. My question is, which view is correct, and why? The question has two parts, and I am interested to hear answers to either or both.
1. Is revealed truth limited to Scripture?
2. What role, if any, does Tradition have in allowing us to understand Scripture?

Please: Kindly support any response you care to share with reasoned support. In other words, please do not simply post dizzying lists of Scriptural passages. For any Scripture you do offer, please provide some explanation of what you take it to be saying and why you take it to say that.

Thank you in advance.
Can you define what you mean by "Tradition" for me. Is this my tradition of Christmas turkey? Or, is it something different?

JoeT
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:41 PM   #4  
Ultra Member
Akoue is offline
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,098
Akoue See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Akoue See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Perhaps I could have been clearer. We use the word "tradition" in lots of different ways, of course. We have family traditions, cultural traditions, I have my own personal "traditions". We I ask about tradition--hereafter Tradition--I mean to ask about a source of revelation. (Presumably my family's traditions aren't a source of revelation for anybody, not even for me.)

I mean Tradition as a body of teaching handed down from one generation to the next. Early Christians called it the "deposit of faith": A body of teaching--to repeat what I just said--that contains truths in matter of faith.

Does this help at all?

(I'm trying to give a sort of neutral presentation of the idea of Tradition.)
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:43 PM   #5  
Jobs & Parenting Expert
Wondergirl is offline
 
Wondergirl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Chicago - western suburbs
Posts: 8,011
Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Like NO said, first look at a tradition's context and history --

In a Zen temple, every evening during meditation the temple's cat would screech at the top of its voice, preventing the monks from concentrating. Eventually the Master had to order the cat to be tied and gagged during meditation sessions, and in this way the problem was solved.

Years passed and both the master and the cat died, and a new master was appointed. Then a new cat was found and every evening before the meditation, it was tied and gagged.

Several years later, scholars at the temple wrote treatises about the significance in Buddhist practice of tying up cats.
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:47 PM   #6  
Über Member
N0help4u is offline
 
N0help4u's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: dark side of moon, Pa
Posts: 16,919
N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.N0help4u See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Send a message via Yahoo to N0help4u
I heard a story about tradition. The woman always cut her meat in half and baked each half in the oven on different racks.
Her husband one time asked why she did it that way. She said I dunno I will have to ask my mother why she did it that way.
She asked her mom. Her mom replied because the oven was too narrow to put a big roasting pan in it so she had to use two smaller ones.
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:55 PM   #7  
Jobs & Parenting Expert
Wondergirl is offline
 
Wondergirl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Chicago - western suburbs
Posts: 8,011
Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Quote:
Originally Posted by N0help4u View Post
I heard a story about tradition. The woman always cut her meat in half and baked each half in the oven on different racks.
Her husband one time asked why she did it that way. She said I dunno I will have to ask my mother why she did it that way.
She asked her mom. Her mom replied because the oven was too narrow to put a big roasting pan in it so she had to use two smaller ones.
I've aways folded towels and washcloths exactly as my mother taught me many years ago. I once asked her why those kinds of folds. She replied, "Because then they will fit in the drawer."

Too often that's what happens with church tradition--"we've always done it that way," but no one knows why and there's no mom to ask why.
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:57 PM   #8  
Ultra Member
Akoue is offline
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,098
Akoue See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Akoue See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Wondergirl, N0help4u,

Thanks. Okay, so I think this helps. So what I want to get at is a notion of Tradition as something the goes beyond the examples you've offered. (Though I would like to here more about the Zen one sometime.--No offense, N0help4u, too soon after Thanksgiving for me to even think about turkey yet).

So, back to my original question: What are your views about Tradition in *that* sense?
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 08:58 PM   #9  
Ultra Member
arcura is offline
 
arcura's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Montana
Posts: 3,021
arcura See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.arcura See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
I think what you are asking about is what the early Church Fathers wrote and taught that was not included in the bible and is referred to as Christian early tradition.
We get that tradition information from still existing documentation.
That does not include later activities such as the CHRISTmas Tree or turkey for CHRISTmas dinner.
Am I right?
Fred
 
 
     
 
 
Old Dec 10, 2008, 09:00 PM   #10  
Jobs & Parenting Expert
Wondergirl is offline
 
Wondergirl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Chicago - western suburbs
Posts: 8,011
Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.Wondergirl See this member's comment history on his/her Profile page.
Please name some specific early church traditions that are still kept and help Christians in some way (and how).
 
 
     


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

 
Similar Sponsors


Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page

Similar Threads
Sola Scriptura vs Church, Sacred Tradition and Scripture
(191 replies)
Did Jesus leave us Tradition or Scripture?
(49 replies)
Interracial Relationship and Tradition
(8 replies)
Jewish Tradition:
(2 replies)
Maritime Wedding Tradition
(0 replies)

Search this Thread

Advanced Search

Bookmarks

Sponsors



Copyright ©2003 - 2009, Ask Me Help Desk.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:21 AM.